(Untitled)

[dine7184]

Unfortunately we have to say goodbye to....

Comments

[chris4short]

oh. hey i got far. can I have my not so nice comments?

edit: that would be group 2 and single 3

[tiah15]

They hated my set more than yours though :)

[chris4short]

you are the one they liked better over all. :) next time it will be you against me! *puppy eyes at Dine* there has to be a next one! it was fun!

[tiah15]

You against me ? You do know that I got lucky, right ? Like I said before - I'm hit and miss ;)

[tiah15]

I'm second in a LIMS - WOW!

Let's hear the comments.
Set #3 and Lyrics #1

[dine7184]

Oh, you can still become first, you know. ;)

Set:
#03 - lovely, but too much going on
#03 - the first has an overall to brownish coloring, the second has a bad cut, and bad use of brushes/textures
#03 - On the Black and White icon, putting the shaded brush over Stella's face obscures details. The coloring of the other icon is very orange.

Lyric Icon:
#01 - The choice of cap doesn't make sense with the text, the cap could be sharpened.

#01 - great combination of text and picture/crop
#01 - the text and the crop are brilliant

[tiah15]

Thanks :) And highly unlikely but I'll try my best ;)

[zeldaophelia]

Set #1 and icon #2 please.

[dine7184]

I really love your Danny icon. :)

Set:
#01 - simple, solid and good colors
#01 - first has an amazing text, coloring, the second is a good crop which make it the best set
#01 - interesting cropping of the B&W icon, fun use of text on the other
#01 - The Black and White icon has awesome detail and coloring, and the cropping is interesting. The other icon has a fun caption.

Lyric Icon:
#02 - Great match of scene to use with the text and the scratch texture adds interest and depth to the icon.
#02 - really good text, which goes with the cap, nice coloring, nice crop