damn...

Jun 17, 2007 23:58

well, this is a disappointment. I got voted off animanga_lims after only 2 rounds that I participated in. it was defintely not my best icon, but still, I didn't think it was that bad.

my critiques )

animanga_lims, sad rose, disappointed rose, my icon making skillz phail me

Leave a comment

Comments 14

sinspire June 18 2007, 04:14:47 UTC
Aw, don't get to down! There have been MASS amounts of elimination each week. And besides, the comeback challenge is right around the corner!

Reply

noroi_inu June 18 2007, 04:31:08 UTC
that's very true! 8O hopefully the comeback challenge will be something I can easily work with. 8D;;;

Reply


koizumi June 18 2007, 04:41:10 UTC
"a more interesting colour treatment (see your Hijikata neighbor icon ;j),"

That was rude. ._.;

Aw, I'm really sorry ♥ Like sinspire said, there are toooons of eliminations, so don't feel too bad. Plus the comeback challenge is coming! 8D

Reply

noroi_inu June 18 2007, 15:27:55 UTC
yeah, that comment pissed me off. --;

but yeah, I don't feel too bad about getting eliminated. I've only been making icons again since...well, probably like 2 weeks before the first challenge. I took it to get back into the habit. 8D;

Reply


yoh_kun June 18 2007, 05:11:31 UTC
I agree with what shannonsu said. That comment was just plain rude. :[ People need to learn the difference between giving constructive criticism and just being mean. D:

And just because your icon got voted off doesn't mean it was bad at all! Submitting icons for an icon post and submiting icons for lims are two different thing, unfortuantely. What works great for an icon dump might end up being eliminated from an itest if it's not shiney or eye-catching enough. x( I happened to think that your icon was pretty~ ♥♥

Reply

noroi_inu June 18 2007, 15:28:57 UTC
aww~ thank you! 83

Reply


ignored_tears June 18 2007, 06:33:27 UTC
Aww, don't let it get you down! There's always the Comeback Round. ^_^b

I agree with shannonsu as well, that is just...so infuriating. What makes people think they have the right to insult someone like that? If I were the mod, I probably would've told them "Excuse me, please redo your crit, you're being a bitch. 8|"

Reply

noroi_inu June 18 2007, 15:30:08 UTC
yeah, I would have probably done something like that too. I stared at that comment in anger for awhile when I read it. --;

Reply


wet_n_flammable June 18 2007, 11:28:26 UTC
i knew that dude looked familiar, i loved Peacemaker Kurogane.

Shinsengumi for life, let the wolves of mibu roam the streets of kyoto for all time.
yes, i'm aware that i'm a loser....

anyways, to the point of this comment. From a fan of the show, i think you did a really good job capturing obito's spirit. In the show, he always acts super sweet and nice to everyone and always smiles, then he goes out and kills like 50 people in cold blood. The darktones really capture that well.

Reply

noroi_inu June 18 2007, 15:31:36 UTC
sankyuu~! ^^

Reply


Leave a comment

Up