Leave a comment

Comments 20

twembachen August 5 2008, 20:32:01 UTC
Also ich hab das jetzt nicht gelesen, weil ich erst bei Seite 250 bin. Aber darf ich aus deinem Cut-Text entnehmen, dass du das Buch nicht magst? :( Das ist schade :(

Reply

no_apologies_86 August 6 2008, 06:51:44 UTC
Ja... ich mag das Buch nicht.

Gefällts dir denn bis jetzt?

Reply

twembachen August 6 2008, 17:57:34 UTC
Also ich finde das Buch bis jetzt ganz gut.
Ich fand es toll, dass sie endlich geheiratet haben und auch ma endlich im Bett gelandet sind. *lol*
Naja, das Bella schwanger wurde hätte ich irgendwie nicht erwartet...

Und nun hänge ich im Jacob Buch. Das gefällt mir nich so gut. Deswegen häng ich da auch noch und komme nicht wirklich weiter. :(

Reply


my_2nd_chance August 5 2008, 21:33:59 UTC
*gives you a hug*

I feel your pain. I'm still waiting to wake up and be like...oh tbank gale that was just an awful dream and now it's Friday and time to go get Breaking Dawn, lol.

Reply

no_apologies_86 August 6 2008, 06:53:27 UTC
*hugs you back*

It's good that at least some people understand an aren't just like oh, I luuuurve the book!.
Gosh, you have no idea how much I wished it was just a dream...

Reply

my_2nd_chance August 7 2008, 16:53:03 UTC
Yeah I think we should kidnap smeyer and make her rewrite it, lol.

Reply


meloncreme August 5 2008, 23:59:01 UTC
Exactly.
The only thing I'm not angry over is the lack of a sex scene. As much as I would've liked to read it, this book is really essentially categorized as a children's novel.

But everything else. Was complete bs. Yes, I agree about Edward being able to see into Bella's mind in the end. That was great.
But the whole thing was just so... *pulls hair out*

It was just a joke.

Reply

no_apologies_86 August 6 2008, 06:55:53 UTC
The only thing I'm not angry over is the lack of a sex scene. As much as I would've liked to read it, this book is really essentially categorized as a children's novel.

Hmm, not really. It's categorised as a young adult novel, and I don't see why there would be anything wrong with a sex scene. Like I said, I didn't want her to write smut, just something.

It was just a joke.

Exactly. A very very bad one :/

Reply


wepretend August 6 2008, 11:24:10 UTC
Ich muss sagen, ich hab mich jetzt ein wenig gespoilert. Aber nicht nur, weil ich ein wenig von diesem Eintrag gelesen habe, sondern auch von anderen Leuten auf meiner F-list. Ich muss vielleicht endlich mal Eclipse zu Ende bringen, damit ich auch mitreden kann. Hmm. Ich hab mir aber ehrlich gesagt schon gedacht, dass das nicht gut enden kann. Irgendwann reicht's mal. Und anscheinend sind ihr die guten Ideen (meiner Meinung nach) beim zweiten Teil schon ausgegangen.

Reply

no_apologies_86 August 10 2008, 21:35:09 UTC
Ich hab mir aber ehrlich gesagt schon gedacht, dass das nicht gut enden kann.

Ja, ich hab auch nicht wirklich damit gerechnet dass BD gut wird, aber das es so schlecht wird hätte ich auch nicht gedacht! Klar, Twilight war super und dann ging's langsam aber stetig bergab... wobei ich sagen muss, dass ich New Moon und Eclipse trotzdem zumindest teilweise gut fand.

Reply


lolz_loser August 6 2008, 23:21:05 UTC
"Jacob's POV. Nothing against Jake here, I liked getting into his head for a while. But it was so bad for the story to change the POV at such a crucial point. It made me lose Bella completely. I just didn't get her anymore after that."

God I had the same problem, but I couldn't figure out why. The third part of the book just lacked SO much for me. I had no idea how to identify with the character anymore!

"and I didn't like it at all that Bella realized she was in love with him too at the end of Eclipse."

YEAH WTF. that just made me go YOU ARE A STUPID TEEN. YOU DONT KNOW WHAT LOVE IS. Thats why I hated jacob!

ugh...if you wanna read my thoughts they're here at my journal

http://lolz-loser.livejournal.com/11929.html

Reply

no_apologies_86 August 10 2008, 21:36:46 UTC
YEAH WTF. that just made me go YOU ARE A STUPID TEEN. YOU DONT KNOW WHAT LOVE IS. Thats why I hated jacob!

Exactly.

ugh...if you wanna read my thoughts they're here at my journal

Will do!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up