Comments | new_shinra87: Final Fantasy 7 What If's

neo_rufus in new_shinra87

Final Fantasy 7 What If's

Feb 28, 2006 15:39

Below are 5 FF7 "what if" questions I thought off, and just wanted to see what kind of responses I would get from you guys. Ill probably do a few of these every so often, so give it a try if you wish, I think it'll be fun. :D ( Read more... )

avatar episodes, questions, what if, ff7

Comments 8

firestorm717 February 28 2006, 20:58:14 UTC

1) Better most likely because Sephiroth played on Cloud's identity confusion to manipulate him through much of the game. Zack's also fought him before and is on the whole much stronger to begin with, as demonstrated in Last Order.

2) Definitely. Quite a bit obsessed over him right now. I'd give up Aeris probably...well, ok, so she's integral to the plot. Cait Sith then because I never used him and I would've preferred an actual person...Reeve...whomever with a gun than a bullhorn wtf.

3) Oh, the age old question. That's tough, because we don't know who it is that would get him through the Lifestream identity thing. But also, I think...hm...Cloud and Tifa have more history, plus Aeris's affection is a lot more motherly IMO what with the whole planet thing.

4) Undoubtedly, though I haven't seen much reference to it in Dirge of Cerberus. He's got ambition and drive, he seems to be pulling many of the strings in the background of AC. I think he'd be better than the original Shinra was, especially given how people perceive them, but he ( ... )

neo_rufus March 6 2006, 16:01:14 UTC

Sorry it took me forever to reply, my bad ( ... )

nosignalinput February 28 2006, 22:49:17 UTC

3.) With tits like that who wouldn't? :p

neo_rufus March 6 2006, 16:03:46 UTC

Lol. :P

mimi_sardinia March 1 2006, 04:48:18 UTC

1. Zack would do better I think, he didn't have Cloud's mental problems (I did glance at firestorm717 answer on that and I agree with it).

2. Hmm... Probably, I always get Sarevok on my team in Throne of Bhaal so I kinda like the reformed bad boy thing (If you don't know ToB, it's the expansion to Baldur's Gate 2 and the final part of the series. Sarevok was the bad guy in BG1 ( ... )

neo_rufus March 6 2006, 16:15:23 UTC

1.) I agree with firestorm717's response as well. Zack is the better choice. At first I thought it was Cloud, but his answer changed my mind. In a way it's probably the same case with Seifer and Squall, like Edea took the stronger warrior.

2.) I've never played that game before, but I will look into it. I'd give up a character for Rufus Shinra any day lol.

3.)Hmm I see. Your right though, I should have thought reconsidered asking that question, it is a bit too hard to debate over.

4.) Very good pont there. I'd say the people would forgive him, at least he took out a few Weapons that was attacking people. I'm sure it will work put for him. ;)

5.) Summons huh lol, I'm a limit break person all the way, but summoms did have cool attacks though. :D Especially Shiva.

summonerluna March 11 2006, 04:37:09 UTC

1. I don't think the events would have played out the way they did had Zack been the one to live. A butterfly effect sort of thing...while Zack was definitely the stronger of the two (and I personally believe that he was stronger than Sephiroth as well as he's the only one who didn't go Jenova psycho at at least some point)...but the story could not have happened the way it did. Zack probably never would have found his way into Avalanche, and even if he had, and Tifa had recognized him and convinced him to join, similar to an answer I had to a different post, Zack wouldn't have had the same motivation Cloud had for going after Sephiroth...I think Seph probably would have destroyed the planet before they got a chance to face him ( ... )

neo_rufus March 11 2006, 18:22:09 UTC

1.) Yeah Zack's will to hunt and kill Seiphroth was nothing compared to Cloud's. He would have probably focused on Shinra a little bit more, or even forget about both in a way, and find a regular job some where in Midgar. I remember before he was shot he was asking Cloud what he was going to do when he reached, and Zack seemed to not have any worries or anything, which probably signaled that he was no longer worrying about Shinra or Seiphroth. I also agree that Zack was stronger, which he showed in Last Order ( ... )