(Untitled)

Mar 01, 2006 22:27

Sha-san, Cho-san, let me speak to you here, away from Kenobi.

Kenobi came forward with a clue which he claims incriminates the both of you and clearing Lady.

I am inclined to believe that Obi-Wan in the third wolf now. What do you think?

Leave a comment

Comments 19

sexy_roach March 2 2006, 06:31:47 UTC
...

I still think it's Ash.

Reply

n_is_for March 2 2006, 06:33:17 UTC
If you believe Lady is a wolf, Sha-san, then by Cho-san's interpretation of the clue, Ash cannot be a wolf. Do you believe that interpretation or not?

Reply

sexy_roach March 2 2006, 06:37:52 UTC
I'm not following any interpretations anymore, I'm just going with my instincts.

Reply

n_is_for March 2 2006, 06:48:31 UTC
I see. I will keep that option in mind, then. Instinct... is nothing to be scoffed at, sometimes. Mello would lauuuuuuugh if he heard me say that.

At least we have some time to consider, given the way voting is going.

Reply


_diesmiling_ March 2 2006, 06:33:05 UTC
Another clue, is it?

May I ask the text of this clue?

Reply

n_is_for March 2 2006, 06:34:22 UTC
The "All wolves are not men" one, Cho-san - at least, that is who I gather first originated the clue. He claims it means the two of you, as you are not human, and thus, "men."

Reply

_diesmiling_ March 2 2006, 06:37:03 UTC
Ah, I thought perhaps it was yet another clue.

Hmm, yes, I think Obi-Wan is the last wolf, then, or severely misinterpreting the clue. But more likely a wolf. Though, it is true that Gojyo and I are not human.

Reply

n_is_for March 2 2006, 06:40:38 UTC
I am aware of that. However, Sha-san, I am less inclined to believe you a wolf than Obi-Wan.

Reply


_diesmiling_ March 2 2006, 08:14:15 UTC
Well. It certainly wasn't Mustang or Lady, then.

Given how I suspected Lady, I know I will be more suspicious to you all now, then.

But. If you are willing to work with me nevertheless, yes, I very much believe Kenobi-san to be one of the wolves, under the previous "If not Roy-san, then Kenobi-san, if not Kenobi-san, then Roy-san" theory.

Reply

_diesmiling_ March 2 2006, 08:20:15 UTC
To ... continue.

Gojyo is a sheep because he received a clue that Roy-san's clue certainly confirmed, etc etc.

Everyone else is unconfirmed, yourself and myself included.

Here was my previous list of possibilities, ignoring yourself and myself as, having come this far... well. Although, given recent turn of events, I expect probably you'd want to measure those possibilities as well. Still, I don't need to work out my own option, and I'm going to continue to discount you, N-san, as having bid this much on the possibility that you are sheep, I feel obliged to go to the line over that gamble.

Ash/Roy
Ash/Lady
Ash/Obi-Wan
Ash/Tobias
Roy/Lady
Roy/Obi-Wan
Roy/Tobias
Lady/Obi-wan
Lady/Tobias
Obi-Wan/Tobias

Now, to remove all Lady and Roy options:

Ash/Obi-Wan
Ash/Tobias
Obi-Wan/Tobias

Two of those three are wolves. One is innocent.

Reply

n_is_for March 2 2006, 08:35:34 UTC
...my personal belief at this point is that it is either you and Tobias, or Obi-Wan and Tobias. Of course, I believed that both Lady and Mustang were wolves, so my instincts are clearly off base. If I were Mello I'd be keyboard mashing.

I have trusted you for the last several days, and you continue to trust me - it would be very unwise of me to toss you away now, unless more compelling evidence is brought against you.

Reply

_diesmiling_ March 2 2006, 08:47:15 UTC
Hmm ... A lot of the debate seems to be if Kenobi-san is the last wolf or if Ash-san is, so ... I suppose it's fair to vote on Tobias-san and hope it isn't both Ash-san and Kenobi-san, after all. At least... until more information shows up. Though ... Regarding Ash-san, I note that if this theory ( here) was at all valid (which, as I warned at the time, it might not be, and of course it still might not be), then Ash-san would have to be a wolf. I must admit I find it odd that Ash-san left one comment on your theorizing post but nothing else. Mind ... at this point, I have lost quite a bit of confidence in that interpretation of the number clue. It's quite a tricky number clue in general.

Mmm... for now ... Tobias-san is where I'll put my suspicion, and I suppose we'll see what happens clue-wise and so on tomorrow.

Ah, and thank you, by the way.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up