Comments | mysticxf: whatever happened, happened because of kate

mysticxf

whatever happened, happened because of kate

Apr 02, 2009 12:35

This is a bit long, but it's a Kate episode, and I could have made it longer - maybe they'll retouch upon a couple of things next week that I didn't mention and I can bring it up then. Heh. Many thanks to carrielynne2323 who's been posting my reviews for me since my job is full of internet Nazi's.

( one more reason to hate her: she's the reason this show exists )

tv: lost s5

Comments 17

yas_m5 April 2 2009, 20:46:37 UTC

like I said, and it's all I can say really, a big fat THANK YOU!!
ad I am listening to everything you tell me today, honest. I have had four sodas in 3 hours. I think I'm gonna burst now :p

starr3d April 2 2009, 21:12:14 UTC

Excellent review! I pretty much agree with everything you said. I wasn't the biggest fan of Kate in this ep, but you're making me see it in a different light. :)

10esmani12191 April 2 2009, 21:13:32 UTC

I have to say, I know a lot of people that were a bit annoyed at Kate on the island with Sawyer because it seemed like the writers kept pushing the two of them together in SOME way when all of that mess should be done and over with, but no one looks deep into the true meaning behind anything like this. All I have to say is "I bow down to you." I think that sums everything up (:

orlikins_lerver April 2 2009, 21:25:45 UTC

*applauds* I always love reading and look forward to your reviews. Because most of the things you say I agree with. While it saddens me that our Jack is conflicted on how to exactly deal with things; I liked how you laid out Kate's dealing.

Your reviews are always well written and well thought out. While I find myself scrambling and rambling on about random things that pop up in my head during the episode. XD! Keep up the good reviewing.

natih April 2 2009, 22:28:39 UTC

I just rewatched the episode...and you know what? there's no way Skate will ever happen again

did I like to see Kate pining for Sawyer (kinda)? No, of course not...and even though everything seemed forced...they needed to show to the audience that Kate did cared about Sawyer after 5x07...

and I get that (even though I don't like it)...nonetheless....I don't want Jate just because Skate is over...I really hope we'll get to see Kate's ILY to Jack on a FB...because that will show us once and for all that she has always loved him...Sawyer or no Sawyer