Comments | mummyluvr314: In His Element: A theory on Dean's confession in 4.11

mummyluvr314

In His Element: A theory on Dean's confession in 4.11

Jan 16, 2009 10:51

( The things my mind creates sometimes, I swear... )

Comments 31

albeitslowly January 16 2009, 19:25:13 UTC

I know as Deangirl I'm not supposed to want Evil!Dean to come to pass, but I so do. It make things so much more interesting. Plus, I may or may not be writing a story that kinda deals with the aftermath of Lucifer!Dean. LOL. But you know, the stuff I wish would happen never does, so we'll probably get some watered down version.

mummyluvr314 January 16 2009, 20:41:32 UTC

Evil!Dean is scary. And I may or may not be writing as story that... is kind of a combination of these two metas... *cough*

albeitslowly January 16 2009, 20:48:22 UTC

Haha, your metas are so inspirational. I gave up even trying to speculate, because I always get so disappointed by how things turn out, but I have no qualms stealing yours and running with them, lol.

Haha, lookie here, I already commented on this. I are obviously not always paying attention to where I am. lol.

yourlibrarian January 16 2009, 19:59:37 UTC

Actually, I don’t think he is. I think he’s in Dean.

In my previous meta I talked about the reasoning behind trapping Lucifer in a mortal. According to John Milton, it’s better to reign in Hell than to serve in Heaven; if you really want to, you can make a Heaven out of Hell. So let’s not give the Devil what he wants. Let’s not make him the leader. Let’s make him suffer.

That's an interesting idea. I suspect that's not where they're going with it, but it would be a great twist.

mummyluvr314 January 16 2009, 20:43:03 UTC

I would love it if they did something different, though. Something to separate Super from all of the other shows that have brought/stopped the Apocalypse, you know? Something that keeps people talking even after season 5 has ended.

But, yeah. They're probably thinking Jesus!Dean and AC!Sam.

yourlibrarian January 16 2009, 20:53:49 UTC

I know, the show has a lot going for it but long-term thinking is not one of their strengths.

pinkphoenix1985 January 16 2009, 20:22:58 UTC

this is amazing!

mummyluvr314 January 16 2009, 20:43:19 UTC

Thanks *blushes*

andromakhe001 January 16 2009, 21:13:03 UTC

I hate this idea. I really do. It really strips Dean of anything for himself and makes it nothing about HIM. It's also a cheap bait and switch. It's not clever at all.

mummyluvr314 January 16 2009, 21:28:26 UTC

All right. Fair enough.

I was just tyring to find reasoning behind sending Dean to Hell, keeping him there for four months/forty years, nad having him enjoy torturing people. Actually, when the idea behind this one hit me, I was trying to defend Dean, if that makes sense. People on another board were saying that him actually ENJOYING what he did was character assassination, and since I'd just posted the other meta yesterday and it all fit...

But I doubt that the actual show would do this. Sam's been the AC for going on 4 years now, and although I do love a good red herring, I doubt anything's going to change. Looks like it's Jesus!Dean and his SWAT Team of angels to the rescue... actually, I wouldn't mind seeing that, either (LOL).

^_^ rae666 January 16 2009, 22:09:54 UTC

So glad I'm not the only person considering this idea. I love the way you bring so much together... scarily, it all fits and makes perfect sense so if it was the route they chose, I wouldn't complain.

Re: ^_^ mummyluvr314 January 16 2009, 22:26:37 UTC

That's right! You wrote Dean as Lucifer. I remember now! Gosh, it's scary how some things come together, isn't it? *shudders* Can't wait to see where they go with this season's mytharc.