Challenge 06 - Voting

[naginis]

A skip has been used for abyss_valkyrie.

The following failed to enter and had no skips to carry them through, and therefore have been eliminated:
dixon

Comments

[abyss_valkyrie]

1 least quality:
2 - Only because of the crop.It is interesting, but I feel like being able to see a bit of her eyes (or one eye) might have been better. Or using a solid BG with this crop could have worked wonders.

1 favorite:
1

[violateraindrop]

1 least quality:
2 - Okay, this was really hard because I like the coloring. The crop is also not bad, but there is something off about it due to the wooden beam in the background. It seems to slice the icon in half in a weird way. Maybe making it lighter or removing the background would have worked better here,

1 favorite:
1 - I just really like the lighting here!

[vapor]

1 least quality:
4 - it's a bit oversharpened and the contrast is high

1 favorite:
3 - nice flat colors and good crop

[sietepecados]

1 least quality:
#2 - I really like the crop on this one, but it look too dark on my screen, and with the odd angle of the cap it's hard to see what is gong on.

1 favorite:
#3 - lovely coloring and composition