Challenge 06 - Voting

Jul 09, 2021 21:05

A skip has been used for timewithers.

Under here )

!voting, round 35

Leave a comment

Comments 6

sandy79 July 9 2021, 21:37:35 UTC
1 least quality:
#1 - To be honest, I'm not quite sure what the maker wanted to achieve here. Sure, the teal-colored stripes bring some color into the pic, but somewhat, they don't work with Sam, who is, on top of that, a tad too dark for the bright colors of the background.

1 favorite:
#3 - subject placement and the text are just stunning!

Reply


abyss_valkyrie July 10 2021, 11:58:02 UTC
1 least quality:
1 - The subject's edges are a bit too sharp.

1 favorite:
3- I like the colour combination and the various textures and text used in a balanced way.

Reply


violateraindrop July 10 2021, 16:46:29 UTC
1 least quality:
4 - The blue coloring/lighting of the original screencap does not fit the background at all. It makes it look as if the cutout subject was simply pasted into the background. It would work much better if at least the different blues of the flag and the subject matched.

1 favorite:
3 - Nice composition!

Reply


dixon July 11 2021, 17:36:18 UTC
1 least quality:
#1 - The coloring is nice, but the crop looks a bit awkward since it's not centered but it's not a side crop either. Also, some parts are a bit oversharpened like his ear and head.

1 favorite:
#3 - Nice composition

Reply


lady_kingsley July 11 2021, 18:07:42 UTC
1 least quality:
4 - While the matching US flag is a nice accent for the background it doesn't match with character's coloring and sharpness.

1 favorite:
2 - Great subtle coloring and sharpess, a halo over the Cap's head is a really nice idea.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up