Challenge 03 Voting

[naginis]

Skips have been used for nightbulbs ninjasinpyjamas & sietepecados.

The following failed to enter and had no skips to carry them through, and therefore have been eliminated:
arbdhax

Comments

[violateraindrop]

1 least quality:
1 - First of all I have to say that this is not a bad icon! The texture overpowers the icon a little bit. A little more light would have helped here. The text looks pixelated and maybe a little bit harsh compared to the dark background.

1 favorite:
4 - The composition and coloring is awesome!

I also really like the background and text placement on 6.
The composition of 7 is very nice, too.

[vanessa_lj]

1 least quality:
# 7 - The texture of the background is too bright and showy, further down it covers the right side of the subject

1 favorite:
# 6

[second_love]

1 least quality:
#5 - the main subject is a little bit blending with background it would look better with yellow bg and red text behind her and red stripes on the right& And I would gauge the font to one of the classic one (not handwritten)

1 favorite:
#3 - like colors and composition

[lady_kingsley]

1 least quality:
1 - Although there is a nice effort put in the icon, the final touch is not ideal - icon looks too dark (maybe some lightning could help in here, or slightly diifferent usage of textures) also the Cap's body as well as font are a bit too blurry.

1 favorite:
5 - Great contrast (amazingly done giving the original screencap!), and true, natural and vivid colors give such great outcome!

[julie_izumi]

1 least quality:
#7 - The background used is a bit overpowering, my attention is more drawn to the skull than on the character.

1 favorite:
#2 - Lovely coloring!