1 least quality: 3 - I do like the 3D effect, but it makes the subject look too blurry. You can barely see her face. There's also a little too much going on in this icon. The background paired with the 3D effect and animation is too busy. Focusing on one or two elements would have worked better here.
1 favorite: 1 - I love the composition and coloring!
1 least quality: 3 - (reason): I think the icon is to saturate about effect 3d (on the girl and the bg) that makes the girl look lq to me, I think that animation and 3d this way don´t get to well I guess. I think if the icon could have one or the another, it could be a good job.
1 favorite: 2 - (reason optional): love the composition+colors here!
1 least quality: 1 - First of all, let's say that all the icons are wonderful. I'm voting out this one just because I've found one little flaw in the cutout and coloring of Valkyrie: she seems washed out in comparison to the other two characters and there is a weird white outline around her.
1 least quality: 3 - The composition overall looks really good, but she looks very dark and the animation is a bit messy, like the sparkly effect is out of order.
Comments 4
3 - I do like the 3D effect, but it makes the subject look too blurry. You can barely see her face. There's also a little too much going on in this icon. The background paired with the 3D effect and animation is too busy. Focusing on one or two elements would have worked better here.
1 favorite:
1 - I love the composition and coloring!
Reply
3 - (reason): I think the icon is to saturate about effect 3d (on the girl and the bg) that makes the girl look lq to me, I think that animation and 3d this way don´t get to well I guess. I think if the icon could have one or the another, it could be a good job.
1 favorite:
2 - (reason optional): love the composition+colors here!
Reply
1 - First of all, let's say that all the icons are wonderful. I'm voting out this one just because I've found one little flaw in the cutout and coloring of Valkyrie: she seems washed out in comparison to the other two characters and there is a weird white outline around her.
1 favorite:
#4
Reply
3 - The composition overall looks really good, but she looks very dark and the animation is a bit messy, like the sparkly effect is out of order.
1 favorite:
4 - Very nice coloring and contrast.
Reply
Leave a comment