Challenge 11 Voting

Mar 18, 2016 21:06

CHALLENGE 11 VOTING

Under here )

!voting, round 12

Leave a comment

Comments 7

gribouille March 18 2016, 20:34:04 UTC
1 least quality:
2 - The background is nice, however Magneto's face looks a bit too blurry on my screen, especially around his forehead and over his eyes, on the left side of the icon; his expression looks a bit odd because of it. The way his ears are cut off also looks a bit unflattering, they look a bit flat.

1 favorite:
1 - Very creative, interesting use of texture.

Reply


lady_turner March 18 2016, 23:07:20 UTC
1 least quality:
#1 - The icon is very creative, but there are some flaws and elements that could have been improved. First of all, his hair on the left look too sharpened and rigid on my screen. While the transparency of the snake is nice on the top (the tattoo effect is eye-catchy and well executed), in the bottom of the icon it doesn't seem a good idea because both the background and part of his face can be seen through the skin of the animal. I'd like to suggest to give more relevance to the snake, especially in the bottom, deleting the transparency and maybe giving it more colours in order to give to the icon a more dynamic look. Moreover, the symbolism of the snake doesn't fit very well the character and it seems that you're watching an icon from another fandom.

1 favorite:
#4

Reply


setentpet March 19 2016, 23:08:07 UTC
1 least quality:
# 2- The background coloring is nice but he almost seems too blurred, especially on the right side of his face.

1 favorite:
#3 - (reason optional)

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

naginis March 20 2016, 13:05:25 UTC
Can you please re-phrase your first sentence? I'm not sure what you mean.

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

naginis March 20 2016, 17:14:55 UTC
Yes, thank you!

Reply


loka_bones March 20 2016, 15:52:19 UTC
1 least quality:
2 - it is strange the color of the background and the face, the face also seems a little blurry and it is dark in the right side of the icon

1 favorite:
3 - Good use of the fake background and use of quimic symbols

Reply


Leave a comment

Up