Challenge 09 Voting

Mar 04, 2016 21:04

A skip has been used for fassy.
The following has chosen to drop out:
adriftingsea

Under here )

!voting, round 12

Leave a comment

Comments 6

burntheflaws March 4 2016, 20:31:10 UTC
1 least quality:
1 - The colors are nice, but the image looks blurry at parts, especially on the sides of his face. It makes him look a little hazy as a result.

1 favorite:
3 - I'm not as fond of the text composition, but I really like the rest of it. Great vivid colors and contrast.

Reply


gribouille March 4 2016, 21:06:53 UTC
1 least quality:
5 - Interesting composition and use of text, but on my screen it looks like there's a bit too much contrast around Xavier's head, his hair is a bit too dark while his face looks washed out.

1 favorite:
4 - Nice crop and use of light!

Reply


delamort March 4 2016, 23:10:02 UTC
(It's becoming increasingly harder to vote, since every icon is great x_x)

1 least quality:
#2: I really like the overall composition and the bg texture, and the blue/cyan coloring!
But the coloring on the left side of the subject's face (right side of the icon) is a little too dark, and there are a bunch of really dark spots that makes it look very unnatural, like on his cheek and under his eye - though I get that the pouch under his eyes is natural, it just looks a bit more pronounced in the icon. His face also looks more sharpened than the rest, but that might be just my monitor
(Sorry for the long comment, I just didn't know how to be as specific in less words >_>)

1 favorite:
#5: The combination of complexity and negative space is wonderfully done, and the coloring is beautiful.

Reply


loka_bones March 5 2016, 13:05:03 UTC
1 least quality:
4 - The icon is dark, it is difficult to appreciate her face in the right side. Maybe a fake background and another coloring had been more appropriate

1 favorite:
3 - Very original composition and good use of the text

Reply


setentpet March 5 2016, 20:28:38 UTC
1 least quality:
#1 - The vibrant coloring is great but there is just something off with his face, it is a bit too dull/flat within all that vibrant coloring. Some contrast would have helped it pop out a little more.

1 favorite:
#2 - (reason optional)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up