Comments | mostly_irish: The Ideal Mate: Vampire or Werewolf? Discuss.

mostly_irish

The Ideal Mate: Vampire or Werewolf? Discuss.

Feb 04, 2009 12:22

This morning, my dear friend and book-devouring dynamo, prncssdidi, started a spirited debate between herself, her hub (aka Sweet Boy), and yours truly over this article ( Read more... )

twilighty, stephen king

Comments 22

whitehousemom February 4 2009, 18:39:31 UTC

Eww, no. I was never attracted to Jacob. He's too immature or something...has rubbed me the wrong way since the beginning. Edward all the way, although, his "nobility" gets on my nerves from time to time.

mostly_irish February 4 2009, 18:53:27 UTC

I know I am in the vast majority, of course. But I seriously think that too much perfection is just downright DULL. Maybe that's why I liked Movie Edward so much. The actor managed to bring a little lightness to the role.

mostly_irish February 4 2009, 18:54:10 UTC

MINORITY. Vast "minority." Duh.

You knew what I meant.

mvance69 February 4 2009, 19:14:04 UTC

Have you seen Underworld....

mostly_irish February 4 2009, 19:22:30 UTC

Um, the Kate Beckinsale movies? Nope. Why?

mvance69 February 4 2009, 19:26:13 UTC

deals with the whole vamp vs were history.

mostly_irish February 4 2009, 19:35:12 UTC

Does it deal with who is more datable? ;)

Thread 8

pinkpiper222 February 4 2009, 20:15:10 UTC

I

LOVE

EDWARD

Well, I really love ROBERT PATTISON, but same thing, yes?

mostly_irish February 4 2009, 20:53:14 UTC

See, NO! I don't think it's the same thing. I totally prefer Robert Pattison Edward over Book Edward. RP Edward is more relateable to me for some reason.

pinkpiper222 February 5 2009, 13:26:30 UTC

( ... )

pinkpiper222 February 5 2009, 13:29:08 UTC

I had never heard of the TWILIGHT books before this summer, so I went to the official movie website to check out what it was even about and saw his picture before I actually bought the book, so I've always pictured his face from the beginning.....

( ... )

Thread 9

darkangel_uk February 5 2009, 18:21:59 UTC

Hmm choices choices. I loved book Edward but hated movie Edward. He did nothing for me, which was sadly disappointed.

If I had to choose though, for myself, I'd probably go for werewolf over vampire. The whole cold as marble thing? Not so good for snuggling. I prefer something a bit hot-blooded! Plus being able to change into a wolf is pretty damn cool.

mostly_irish February 5 2009, 19:38:12 UTC

Ooooh, you're right. I didn't even think of the cold vs. hot issue. I am constantly chilly as it is...I don't need some icy marble boyfriend making things worse! I'd need to constantly walk around in one of those horrid Snuggie Blanket robe-things. You know, the bizarre article of clothing Paula blogged about a while back?

Snuggie does not equal Sexy.