Comments | mkalims: Round #10 - Challenge #5

hermionesparkle in mkalims

Round #10 - Challenge #5 - Results

Nov 30, 2009 02:53

Sorry this toke so long, thanks to everyone who voted!

Sadly we are saying goodbye to 1 icon maker tonight:

( Read more... )

round10, results, challenge5

Comments 7

depp_sparrow92 November 30 2009, 15:16:24 UTC

Thank u soo much & Congrats to borninthisworld
I'd like to see my comments :)

borninthisworld November 30 2009, 17:05:02 UTC

Congrats, as well, bb!

hermionesparkle December 1 2009, 04:46:05 UTC

least favorite:
3 - The icon seems just a bit oversharpned, and could use some softening, on her face in particular.
3 - the box texture on the side doesn't fit the icon

favorite:
#3 - Nice crop.
#3 - The coloring is pretty.
#3 - lovely crop, great sharpness to the icon.

depp_sparrow92 December 3 2009, 13:38:19 UTC

Thanks :)

borninthisworld November 30 2009, 17:04:38 UTC

Thanks for the votes!
May I see my comments?

hermionesparkle December 1 2009, 04:47:02 UTC

Sure can. Yours was super duper adorable!! :)

1 - Great crop and nice color!
1. gorgeous crop and the text works well
#01 - Interesting cropping and use of text.

borninthisworld December 1 2009, 13:55:02 UTC

Thanks, bb!