Results Challenge #2

Jul 03, 2006 01:14

I didn't have to many votes this time around and I nearly had a lot of ties. Thanks to those who voted! Here are the results for this week:


Read more... )

results, challenge2, round2

Leave a comment

Comments 15

i_______loveyou July 3 2006, 05:22:08 UTC
#11 please.

Reply

hermionesparkle July 5 2006, 05:14:01 UTC
11. That black brush doesn't fit
11: It's to orange, and the black edge looks a little sloppy
11 the border crops mk out horribly
11 since mk isn't fully cut out it looks odd

fave 11. i love the colours and the cropping

Reply


lilangel89 July 3 2006, 07:42:29 UTC
#8 please.

Reply

hermionesparkle July 5 2006, 05:15:10 UTC
Sorry you got voted out so fast!

8. The gray circle in the center is overpowering to the icon.
8 - The style would be much better if the outer (colouredish) part was actually full colour or sepia or something. The red just looks kind of funny.
08. the black and white circle thrown into the icon makes the icon look off balance.
8. That grey round in the middle ruins the icon
8. The greyscale circle is very awkwardly placed and doesn't compliment the icon.
8- the circular desaturated area looks awkward.

Reply


dirrtydiesel July 3 2006, 08:29:02 UTC
#13 please

Reply

hermionesparkle July 5 2006, 05:16:35 UTC
Sorry you got voted out!

13.Too bright
13. I don't like the cropping
13. Too bright.
13: It's too bright
13 - The icon is way too bright. Also, that is kind of a tackey place to cut off the picture. The picture being moved down a little would be nice, because otherwise her face just stops, whereas the other's face is completely there.
13. I don't like the cropping. If you're going to crop out MK at least do it all the way.
13 the coloring is to bright

Reply


sweetharmony82 July 3 2006, 11:39:34 UTC
#7 please

Reply

hermionesparkle July 5 2006, 05:17:15 UTC
7 the effect makes their faces dark
7- over sharpened

Reply


ninefifteen July 3 2006, 13:38:41 UTC
Weird. votes and favourite-vote =/
#12 please.

Reply

hermionesparkle July 5 2006, 05:18:21 UTC
12. With both faces in the icon and the text and the coloring it's too busy, and it could be sharpened more.
12. The effects on the icon spoil it & take the focus away from the girls.
12 the icon looks messed up
12. The text doesn't fit well with the icon. It's not readable, if it's supposed to be like the tiny text, it needs some work.

Fave: 12. The coloring and cropping is beautiful.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up