Welcome to the Table of Death.
This table documents Sam and Dean's kills and associated violence up to 2x09. It also includes who killed the Monster of the Week, when that was not Sam or Dean.
I know what you're saying... how have I lived without this!
Dean has been responsible for vanquishing 16 supernatural things and Sam for nine. Of these 25 events, seventeen are achieved through the not so blood thirsty methods such as exorcisms, salting and burning etc.
Dean gets violent on eight occasions - shooting (wendigo, shapeshifter, striga, demon boy, infected Mr Tanner), electrocuted (rawhead) and beheaded (vampire). Sam's only real violence was stabbing the rakshasa - which was invisible and behind him at the time.
Information was compiled from my obsessive brain and the wonderful episode Bibles at spn_heavymeta
ETA: I'm sending Sam and Dean around with a plate of cookies for
black_samvara who coded my table so it is a thing of beauty! Thank you sweetie.
Ep. When What How Who 1.01 Pilot Woman in White Shot but not killed Dean Spirit of Constance Welch Banished after reunion with dead children Sam (he takes her home) 1.02 Wendigo Wendigo Flare gun Dean 1.03 Dead in the Water Spirit of Peter Sweeney Banished after all killers are dead Sheriff Jake Devins 1.04 Phantom Traveller Demon Exorcised Sam 1.05 Bloody Mary Bloody Mary Trapped in mirror that is broken Dean 1.06 Skin Shapeshifter Shot Dean 1.07 Hookman Hookman Banished by salting, burning and melting silver from his hook Dean 1.08 Bugs Possessed bugs Time passes Time 1.09 Home Poltergeist Defeated by stronger spirit Mary 1.10 Asylum Dr Ellicot’s spirit Salted and burnt Dean 1.11 Scarecrow Pagan god Sacred tree is burnt Emily 1.12 Faith Rawhead Electrocution Dean Sue Ann Le Grange Reaper, after it’s released from her control Sam 1.13 Route 666 Possessed truck Passes over hallowed ground Dean and Sam 1.14 Nightmare Max Miller Suicide Max 1.15 The Benders Pa Bender Shot Kathryn 1.16 Shadow Meg/Daevas Escaped from rather than defeated 1.17 Hell House Tulpa manifesting as Mordecai House burnt Dean 1.18 Something Wicked Striga Shot Dean 1.19 Provenance Melanie Merchant Salt and burn Dean 1.20 Dead Man’s Blood Vamps Shot with crossbows Sam/Dean/John Vamp!Hank Beheaded John Vamp!Luthor Shot with Colt John Vamp!Random Beheaded Dean 1.21 Salvation 1.22 Devil’s Trap Meg Exorcism Sam Demon boy Shot with Colt Dean 2.01 In My Time of Dying John Bargain with Demon John/Demon 2.02 Everybody Loves a Clown Rakshasa Stabbed with brass pipe Sam 2.03 Bloodlust Vampire Beheaded Dean 2.04 Children shouldn’t Play with Dead Things Zombie Shot Dean same zombie Shot Sam yep her Stabbed Dean 2.05 Simon Said Anson Shot Andy 2.06 No Exit Spirit of H.H. Holmes Trapped Sam/Dean/Jo 2.07 The Usual Suspects Detective Sheridan Shot Detective Ballard 2.08 Crossroad Blues Demon Bargain Dean 2.09 Croatoan Mr Tanner Shot Dean Mrs Tanner Shot Dean Demon virus Disappears Demon