Comments | minviendha: MARCH MADNESS ROUND FIVE (FINAL FOUR!!!)

minviendha

MARCH MADNESS ROUND FIVE (FINAL FOUR!!!)

Mar 17, 2011 21:06

And in this last round, we said farewell to Melian, Jack Harkness, Brynden "The Blackfish" Tully and Jaime Lannister! You fought well, friends, but now we are down to the wire - and the real champion is only two rounds away!

So off we go, with two big matches...

( doctor vs. elf-master )

fandom: lol feanorians, fandom: new face new friends, i am getting really good at polls, fandom: a song of ice and fire

Comments 19

hamsterwoman March 18 2011, 04:40:29 UTC

Brienne beat Jaime once, she can do it again. Also: MWAHAHA.

kitrinlu March 18 2011, 04:50:05 UTC

I think Jaime would win if he still had his hand (after all, when Brienne beat him, he'd just spent the last however-long chained up in a dungeon!), but I choose handless!Jaime to fight and lose, because Brienne rocks XD

chacusha March 18 2011, 04:55:28 UTC

These are pretty epic. O_O

buttheartz March 18 2011, 07:26:38 UTC

As of now, I'm the lone vote for Jaime! But I just don't think Brienne would deal the killing blow. She might hesitate, for just a fleeting moment, what with Jaime handless and all...

tomboy_typist March 18 2011, 22:34:59 UTC

Broke my heart, but I thought the same way it's actually pretty canon, too... though that's assuming the guy has both hands. With one hand, to be fair, Jaime is kind of useless... Guess that's the reasoning the others followed. But Brienne wouldn't strike a man she kinda likes and who can't really fight back, so back to square one. Heh.

Also, Fea totally beats the Doc. Cuz I said so. :|

buttheartz March 19 2011, 11:47:19 UTC

It's magic.

Except for that last part. The Doc regenerates after all. So yeah, he's got this. Sorry Fea.

tomboy_typist March 19 2011, 16:33:40 UTC

Feanor is making his unhappy pouty face at you, Shar. Lookit. Is skeeeeeery.

I swear, he made me vote for him. He did. Save meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee *thudding sound*

Thread 13

sargent_snarky March 20 2011, 03:16:02 UTC

I have not read enough of the Game of Thrones series to vote in the second poll, but I have to side with Feanor in the other one. True, the Doctor is capable of regenerating immediately, whereas Feanor would have to go by way of Mandos' good graces to come back, but Feanor is more ruthless. The Doctor seems like he would hesitate to go for the kill to me, whereas Feanor - in most characterizations thereof - would not. Sure, a Time Lord probably has more innate power than even one of the most powerful Elves, but this isn't about who is more powerful - it's who is more likely to win.

minviendha March 22 2011, 04:45:02 UTC

You actually make a very good point...I'm tempted to change my vote. Although it appears that the Doctor will win anyway. You've convinced me, though - you can know that.

And feel gratified, hopefully? (or something.)

sargent_snarky April 11 2011, 10:25:33 UTC

CHANGE YOUR VOTE ANYWAY!

I mean. Um. :D I did nothing! It was all Feanor and his ruthlessness.