Comments | minviendha: fanfiction is drama.

minviendha

fanfiction is drama.

Apr 17, 2007 21:35

This is an interesting conversation.

Read the comments. Enjoy the drama and the arguments. Actually, there are some very good points buried in all the shooting back and forth between anti-fanficcers and pro-fanficcers.

fandom: robin hobb, fandom: fanfiction

Comments 5

youkokoenma April 18 2007, 07:13:07 UTC

I think the pro-fanficceres (especially that Jaime guy) have the best points--but then again, I'm a little biased. ^_^ Still, Hobb comes off as quite immature in her little rant against fanfiction. A simple "I'd appreciate it if you didn't" would have sufficed, and not made her look like a complete ass. >.>

minviendha April 18 2007, 14:43:45 UTC

I agree. And whenever I read that rant, I just wince at how stupid she made herself sound. Oh, Robin Hobb. For such a good writer, you certainly don't formulate your rants very well.

(The comment has been removed)

minviendha April 18 2007, 14:45:17 UTC

HUGE. PICKLE.

Indeed. Srrsly, if you put your stuff out there, it's in the public domain. Can't we do stuff with it? It no longer belongs exclusively to you, Robin. In other words, IT'S OURS, TOO.

(The comment has been removed)

minviendha April 18 2007, 14:46:31 UTC

Ya, rly.

I don't think there's anything wrong with anything I write fanfiction for. I write fanfiction because I love the characters and want to see more of them.

No way. Fanfic ain't going anywhere.

redsilkscarf April 18 2007, 19:40:02 UTC

THANK YOU! Anne Rice's no-fanfic-or-else thing drives me up the wall, since I'm in the VC fandom. As of late, though, she's gone completely nuts, and has forgotten about her Vampire Chronicles to go write about Jesus. However, Anne and the fanfiction deal... the woman is crazy. You don't have your people cyberstalk fanfiction authors. It certainly didn't stop people from continuing to write fanfiction (now it's all underground), and I think that's the case for any author who's against fanfiction.