But...what IS consciousness?

Jan 20, 2012 14:02

Caitlin and I were just looking at each other, trying to have a psychic conversation like we usually do in classes together, and we were failing due to complete COMPREHENSIVE BANDWIDTH DEPLETION. Intro to philosophy, even through the lens of Star Trek, is THE MOST OVERWHELMING CLASS, with the possible exception of higher level philosophy classes ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 6

trainerjonathan January 21 2012, 04:16:46 UTC
An illusion, a fiction, that is essential to human interaction?

Reply

minionmolly January 24 2012, 17:39:51 UTC
I DON'T UNDERSTAND. At least with religious studies, we eventually get to faith and belief and other happy things that please people and give meaning to their lives. Will I get to meaning in philosophy? Or is philosophy just another religion, wherein the followers seek meaning through their deductive and inductive powers and are constantly stymied?

GAHHHHHH MY BRAIN.

Reply

minionmolly January 24 2012, 17:40:32 UTC
Yes, you're probably right. Will the other philosophers break my brain as much as Descartes?

Reply

trainerjonathan January 24 2012, 18:20:23 UTC
Not sure. Descartes is reacting strongly against the religious philosophers that came before him, and is important in the history of philosophy to understand what other writers are reacting against, but I'm not sure which parts of his philosophy are breaking your brain, so it's tough to say if later philosophers will patch it up or break it further....

Reply


trainerjonathan January 24 2012, 18:25:12 UTC
Descartes thinks that consciousness is this unitary thing (which he never specifically calls a soul), but later philosophers point out that this is horse-shit: people are made of all kinds of conflicting impulses.

Also, I found it useful in philosophy class to assume that any wacky nonsense a given philosopher was spouting was actually supposed to be interpreted as metaphor.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up