(Untitled)

[melyanna]

Quick grammar question:

She didn't know if anyone besides her had noticed.

Should that be besides or beside? Or is this one of those things where either is (annoyingly) correct?

Comments

[laura_josephsen]

It should be "besides"; if you have "beside", it implies she doesn't know if anyone next to her noticed.

[melyanna]

I see the ambiguity there, but then I looked it up and the dictionary said it could be either.

…I think I may go with maerchen's suggestion.

[maerchen]

This is the kind of sentence where I usually write "other than" instead of "besides" to avoid confusion.

[melyanna]

Yeah, I had that thought after I posted, but then LJ was down and I was still curious. ;)

[miera_c]

I was gonna say that too. Dodge the whole question!

[melyanna]

Yeah, discretion being the better part of valor, I reworded. ;)