[2-FINAL] [VOTING] PORTFOLIO, REVISITED (PART THREE - THREE WORST);
'Sup everyone!
This would be part trois and with more copypasta of the three-part voting this round, hoho. Part one can be found right here and part two is over thar.
This is for the SENIOR LEAGUE! Junior League's voting post is here.
Voting isn't obligatory, but HIGHLY recommended! Come on, it's the last round, you know you wanna. ;3
Voting this round is split in 3 parts; you do not have to vote in all three of them if you don't want to.
It's a little different, too, so please give the voting guidelines a read. :3
VOTING RULES
- Finalists may not vote. This is to ensure that their votes don't end up working against themselves.
- Only one vote per person! Don't make fake accounts to vote, or your votes will be nullified (and if you're a participating member, you'll be disqualified!)
- You do not have to give a reason for your choices. I repeat - crits are not necessary. This is to ensure we get the amount of votes necessary for this round to end. However, critiques are still highly appreciated. Votes with critiques are worth twice as much as votes without - so if you can spare the time, please attach reasons to your votes.
- Try to vote fairly, and based on the aesthetic quality rather than your personal preferences. Liking the character/series/artwork is not a valid reason to give a vote! Also, make sure you vote for the icon group as a whole - don't base your vote on liking one icon of the set but hating the rest!
- Make sure you've picked the right icon sets for your votes! The number of the set is above it on the voting table. We'll try to check every vote to make sure it matches the icons, but please be careful!
- You do not need to be a participating member to vote. Anyone can vote, so please vote and encourage others to do the same!
VOTING FORMAT
- Votes for this part must be submitted to this post.
- Please number the sets in the order you like them most - from top favorite to bottom favorite.
- You do not need to include critiques with your votes. However, votes with critiques are worth twice the points of votes without them; this is both to encourage crits and to ensure that crit-less votes do not have as much weight as votes from people who bother explaining their picks. :3
- Voting order DOES matter! Make sure you list the iconsets in order of priority.
Submit your votes as such:
Favorite Sets
[#05] (priority: 1) - I think this set shows more unity of style and a better grasp of technique than the others. I especially like the 2nd icon; it stands out a lot in comparison to the other icons from other sets - but the other two icons are equally awesome, etc etc etc.
[#01] (priority: 2) - [optional crit]
[#03] (priority: 3) - [optional crit]
[#06] (priority: 4) - [optional crit]
[#04] (priority: 5) - [optional crit]
Alternatively you can use this template (replace 'xx' with the icon numbers):
Favorites
[#xx] (priority: 1) - [crit]
[#xx] (priority: 2) - [crit]
[#xx] (priority: 3) - [crit]
[#xx] (priority: 4) - [crit]
[#xx] (priority: 5) - [crit]
And without further ado, on to the iconsets! Please remember you're voting for the sets, not for individual icons within each set!
Voting: Portfolio, Revisited - Three Worst
Remember to rank the icon SETS in order of your preference. Comments are NOT REQUIRED, but votes with critiques will be worth more than votes without. If you do leave critiques, you don't have to leave them for every set, but again, votes without crits will be worth less.
For this part, I gathered (based on overall results and how well the icons did in comparison to the other six finalists) the three worst icons from each finalist in Challenge 02. Voters should pick which set of three 'worst' icons is the um, best of the worst? Each set has icons made by one of the five finalists.
Set #01
Set #02
Set #03
Set #04
Set #05
Set #01
#01 - Round 01 (Manga Battle Tactics - Chemist) - icon had to blend in a real life object.
#02 - Round 06 (Manga?) - icon had to contain a speech bubble.
#03 - Round 07 (This Is Not A Pimping Round - Fashion Show) - icon had to show the clothes of a character and no head.
Set #02
#01 - Round 05 (The Icontest - NO) - icon had to represent "no".
#02 - Round 06 (Manga?) - icon had to contain a speech bubble.
#03 - Round 07 (This Is Not A Pimping Round - Eye Spy) - icon had to have an eye crop.
Set #03
#01 - Round 01 (Manga Battle Tactics - Knight) - icon had to feature two characters.
#02 - Round 04 (I Suggest It Was... In The... With The - Mrs. Peacock, Revolver, Library) - icon had to be predominantly blue, feature a male, have a book in it.
#03 - Round 07 (This Is Not A Pimping Round - Eye Spy) - icon had to have an eye crop.
Set #04
#01 - Round 01 (Manga Battle Tactics - Squire) - icon could not use textures, filters, text, color layers, brushes, or anything outside of the image itself.
#02 - Round 01 (Manga Battle Tactics - Black Mage) - icon had to represent fire, lightning or ice.
#03 - Round 03 (Does Your Neck Itch? - Victims) - icon had to be themed "struggle".
Set #05
#01 - Round 02 (The 2nd Round II of Manga Battle) - icon had to have a redundant caption.
#02 - Round 04 (I Suggest It Was... In The... With The - Colonel Mustard) - icon had to be predominantly yellow.
#03 - Round 07 (This Is Not A Pimping Round - Because I'm Worth It) - icon had to show the hair of a character, no face, no crop below the shoulders.
Voting for this batch will only close after we get at least 25 votes, and after each set has at least 10 critiques each. This means that, if we get 25 votes but some of the sets don't have 10 crits yet, voting will not close; if each set has 10 crits each but we haven't hit 25 votes yet, voting will not close. Both conditions must be met!
This is because we've had serious issues with voting in the past few rounds and, this being the final round, we want to ensure a fair win. So please vote, and encourage others to do so!
I will comment to close voting once those conditions have been met. Votes submitted after the closing will not be counted.
You may split your voting - i.e. vote for a couple of sets now, and a couple later - but your votes will not be counted until you've ranked all 6 sets!
Good luck to all the participants and happy voting!
Please remember to ask any questions you might have, and read the rules carefully. If anything is unclear, ask and we'll try to clarify.
This would be part trois and with more copypasta of the three-part voting this round, hoho. Part one can be found right here and part two is over thar.
This is for the SENIOR LEAGUE! Junior League's voting post is here.
Voting isn't obligatory, but HIGHLY recommended! Come on, it's the last round, you know you wanna. ;3
Voting this round is split in 3 parts; you do not have to vote in all three of them if you don't want to.
It's a little different, too, so please give the voting guidelines a read. :3
VOTING RULES
- Finalists may not vote. This is to ensure that their votes don't end up working against themselves.
- Only one vote per person! Don't make fake accounts to vote, or your votes will be nullified (and if you're a participating member, you'll be disqualified!)
- You do not have to give a reason for your choices. I repeat - crits are not necessary. This is to ensure we get the amount of votes necessary for this round to end. However, critiques are still highly appreciated. Votes with critiques are worth twice as much as votes without - so if you can spare the time, please attach reasons to your votes.
- Try to vote fairly, and based on the aesthetic quality rather than your personal preferences. Liking the character/series/artwork is not a valid reason to give a vote! Also, make sure you vote for the icon group as a whole - don't base your vote on liking one icon of the set but hating the rest!
- Make sure you've picked the right icon sets for your votes! The number of the set is above it on the voting table. We'll try to check every vote to make sure it matches the icons, but please be careful!
- You do not need to be a participating member to vote. Anyone can vote, so please vote and encourage others to do the same!
VOTING FORMAT
- Votes for this part must be submitted to this post.
- Please number the sets in the order you like them most - from top favorite to bottom favorite.
- You do not need to include critiques with your votes. However, votes with critiques are worth twice the points of votes without them; this is both to encourage crits and to ensure that crit-less votes do not have as much weight as votes from people who bother explaining their picks. :3
- Voting order DOES matter! Make sure you list the iconsets in order of priority.
Submit your votes as such:
Favorite Sets
[#05] (priority: 1) - I think this set shows more unity of style and a better grasp of technique than the others. I especially like the 2nd icon; it stands out a lot in comparison to the other icons from other sets - but the other two icons are equally awesome, etc etc etc.
[#01] (priority: 2) - [optional crit]
[#03] (priority: 3) - [optional crit]
[#06] (priority: 4) - [optional crit]
[#04] (priority: 5) - [optional crit]
Alternatively you can use this template (replace 'xx' with the icon numbers):
Favorites
[#xx] (priority: 1) - [crit]
[#xx] (priority: 2) - [crit]
[#xx] (priority: 3) - [crit]
[#xx] (priority: 4) - [crit]
[#xx] (priority: 5) - [crit]
And without further ado, on to the iconsets! Please remember you're voting for the sets, not for individual icons within each set!
Voting: Portfolio, Revisited - Three Worst
Remember to rank the icon SETS in order of your preference. Comments are NOT REQUIRED, but votes with critiques will be worth more than votes without. If you do leave critiques, you don't have to leave them for every set, but again, votes without crits will be worth less.
For this part, I gathered (based on overall results and how well the icons did in comparison to the other six finalists) the three worst icons from each finalist in Challenge 02. Voters should pick which set of three 'worst' icons is the um, best of the worst? Each set has icons made by one of the five finalists.
Set #01
Set #02
Set #03
Set #04
Set #05
Set #01
#01 - Round 01 (Manga Battle Tactics - Chemist) - icon had to blend in a real life object.
#02 - Round 06 (Manga?) - icon had to contain a speech bubble.
#03 - Round 07 (This Is Not A Pimping Round - Fashion Show) - icon had to show the clothes of a character and no head.
Set #02
#01 - Round 05 (The Icontest - NO) - icon had to represent "no".
#02 - Round 06 (Manga?) - icon had to contain a speech bubble.
#03 - Round 07 (This Is Not A Pimping Round - Eye Spy) - icon had to have an eye crop.
Set #03
#01 - Round 01 (Manga Battle Tactics - Knight) - icon had to feature two characters.
#02 - Round 04 (I Suggest It Was... In The... With The - Mrs. Peacock, Revolver, Library) - icon had to be predominantly blue, feature a male, have a book in it.
#03 - Round 07 (This Is Not A Pimping Round - Eye Spy) - icon had to have an eye crop.
Set #04
#01 - Round 01 (Manga Battle Tactics - Squire) - icon could not use textures, filters, text, color layers, brushes, or anything outside of the image itself.
#02 - Round 01 (Manga Battle Tactics - Black Mage) - icon had to represent fire, lightning or ice.
#03 - Round 03 (Does Your Neck Itch? - Victims) - icon had to be themed "struggle".
Set #05
#01 - Round 02 (The 2nd Round II of Manga Battle) - icon had to have a redundant caption.
#02 - Round 04 (I Suggest It Was... In The... With The - Colonel Mustard) - icon had to be predominantly yellow.
#03 - Round 07 (This Is Not A Pimping Round - Because I'm Worth It) - icon had to show the hair of a character, no face, no crop below the shoulders.
Voting for this batch will only close after we get at least 25 votes, and after each set has at least 10 critiques each. This means that, if we get 25 votes but some of the sets don't have 10 crits yet, voting will not close; if each set has 10 crits each but we haven't hit 25 votes yet, voting will not close. Both conditions must be met!
This is because we've had serious issues with voting in the past few rounds and, this being the final round, we want to ensure a fair win. So please vote, and encourage others to do so!
I will comment to close voting once those conditions have been met. Votes submitted after the closing will not be counted.
You may split your voting - i.e. vote for a couple of sets now, and a couple later - but your votes will not be counted until you've ranked all 6 sets!
Good luck to all the participants and happy voting!
Please remember to ask any questions you might have, and read the rules carefully. If anything is unclear, ask and we'll try to clarify.