All your Phelps are...oh, you know

Aug 19, 2008 12:00

Okay, so Michael Phelps is the Greatest Olympian EVAR. Or...is he ( Read more... )

events: olympics

Leave a comment

Comments 16

(The comment has been removed)

sefkhet August 19 2008, 17:47:25 UTC
My personal favourite is still Steve Redgrave

Seconded.

I still tear up at that moment in the Sydney Games when they cross the line, because that was something that none of us had really dared to believe would happen *again*.

Reply

mmichelle August 19 2008, 18:48:52 UTC
I agree. In terms of sheer medals won, Phelps is undoubtedly the greatest Olympian ever, but that's not all that matters to me. I find so much more admirable the accomplishments of people who have gone through hardships, or been perpetual silver medalists, and yet keep coming back and giving it their all and demonstrating that basic respect of the Olympic Games. I think Michael Phelps is great and I'm thrilled for him, and there's no denying how momentous his achievement was, but he's not going on top of my list.

Reply

multi-sport athletes techiebloke August 19 2008, 19:14:51 UTC
Rebecca Romero got a gold (for cycling) and a silver (for rowing). But not at the same games; the silver was in 2004 and the gold was Sunday.

(see
here).

Reply


ex_rogerpit August 19 2008, 17:15:15 UTC
The one thing that stands out for me in this analysis (which is fantastic, by the way - I'd been wondering about this myself) is that you would have to be a man in order to achieve the goal in question. It looks to me like it would be impossible for a woman to even come close to this, unless I'm misreading something. Interesting...

Reply

madlori August 19 2008, 17:51:25 UTC
A woman swimmer or runner would have just the same chance as a man, those sports have nearly identical event lineups.

Reply

coern August 21 2008, 03:57:16 UTC
swimmers have much better chances because of the different strokes. there's really only one way to run. hurdling and running are entirely different disciplines.

Reply


yorick28 August 19 2008, 18:06:03 UTC
I think the question of if anyone has already competed in more than one sport in one Olympics might depend slightly on how strictly you delineate between disciplines; Jackie Joyner-Kersee, as I recall, would compete in both the heptathlon and in some of the individual events that comprised the heptathlon like the long jump ( ... )

Reply

wanderingdame August 19 2008, 19:16:41 UTC
You're right. I used to be a swimmer and it is very hard to focus on more than one stroke. People who swim the Individual Medleys usually have at least one weak stroke. At least. Probably two.

Phelps is good at all of them. It used to be that breakstroke was his weakness, but he worked at it and tweaked his stroke until he can blow most people out of the water even with his "weak stroke".

That's the reason Phelps is one of the greatest Olympians to me. He may not have over come the most obstacles and he may have gotten lucky in competing in one of the few sports that allows this sort of thing, but he has also shown a level of determination and dedication to better himself that is awe inspiring.

Reply


shadist August 19 2008, 19:14:20 UTC
People don't quite think of shooting as quite as much of an athletic achievement.

Until the zombies attack that is.

Reply

39th_year August 19 2008, 21:12:24 UTC
Yeah, it's all "OOOH, Michael" but can he outswim zombies? HUH?

Reply

39th_year August 19 2008, 21:12:58 UTC
And of course now I'm picturing zombie Olympics in my head. Hmmm...

Reply

shadist August 20 2008, 00:24:02 UTC
They are quite happy to walk slowly along the bottom of whatever body of water he cares to swim. :)

Reply


kosarin August 20 2008, 05:08:27 UTC
Sigh... Sucks to be a female in athletics, doesn't it?

Reply


Leave a comment

Up