a garden path in the wild

Jun 23, 2006 23:27


1. The horse raced past the barn fell.
2. The man who hunts ducks out on weekends.
3. Fat people eat accumulates.
4. The tycoon sold the offshore oil tracts for a lot money wanted to kill JR.

These are called garden path sentences---sentences that lead the reader or listener "up the garden path" to an incorrect syntactic analysis. For example, the ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 14

yourdesertrose June 24 2006, 04:49:46 UTC
I tried reading The Scarlet Letter when I was about 10. It didn't work so well. I think I got through it, but probably didn't understand much of what the writer intended. Maybe it's time I reread it, along with a few other things.

Reply


flurious June 24 2006, 04:52:52 UTC
My first reading had "intermixed" as a participle.

Reply

loveschak June 24 2006, 05:06:34 UTC
Well aren't you special.

Reply


tonapah June 24 2006, 07:34:02 UTC
I don't see a way to read your fourth example as a correct sentence.

Reply

loveschak June 24 2006, 14:11:08 UTC
The magnate who was sold the mansion for a low price loved JR, but the tycoon sold the offshore oil tracts for a lot money wanted to kill JR.

Reply

lost1 June 24 2006, 23:04:25 UTC
I still think that sentence requires a "who" or "which" or "that" to make it a valid statement.

the tycoon WHO/WHICH/THAT sold the offshore oil tracks for a lot of money wanted to kill JR.

Reply

loveschak June 25 2006, 00:30:35 UTC
I think you may still be interpreting the sentence wrong. The filler words would be: the tycoon WHO WAS sold the offshore oil tracks for a lot of money wanted to kill JR. It wasn't the tycoon doing the selling, it was the tycoon doing the buying.

English is replete with examples where an object is modified by a participle (or other adjective) coming after it. I captured the man wanted by authorities. Some of the trees planted in the field withered after a while. I'll never be a person apt to gamble. That dye put into your hair looks ridiculous.

Reply


tellumo June 24 2006, 19:26:27 UTC
Interesting. My first interpretation of the first one involved "fell" as the landform, not the verb.

Reply

mollyswanson June 25 2006, 01:40:26 UTC
Hah - must be evidence that you're actually British.

Reply


hooveraardvark June 28 2006, 17:48:19 UTC
hey, i added you - i'm jonah gold's girlfriend.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up