Fic - The Detective - Sherlock BBC/Doctor Who - PG

Apr 11, 2011 09:15

Title: The Detective
Prompt: From Make Me A Monday on sherlockbbc, 28.3.11. the_gabih: What I'd love is a Sherlock/Doctor Who fic echoing the beginning of DW series 5 - just after regenerating, Sherlock crashes into mini!John's back garden. John nurses him back to health, and in return Sherlock promises he'll come back for him when the TARDIS engines are fixed. John ( Read more... )

fandom: general, fandom: doctor who, rating: pg, character: sherlock holmes, character: john watson, fandom: sherlock, genre: crossover, verse: the detective, fic

Leave a comment

Comments 138

seaweedie April 11 2011, 08:34:16 UTC
OH MY GOD YOU ARE MADE OF SUNSHINE AND RAINBOWS AND PROBABLY GLITTER

A SEASON5!WHO/SHERLOCK CROSSOVER I CAN'T EVENNNNN /CLUTCHES AT

okay i can't read this yet but WHEN I FINISH MY HOMEWORK I'M COMING BACK HERE FIRST THING

Reply

best homework break ever? i think so seaweedie April 11 2011, 09:21:03 UTC
I love this, I love all of this so much, you don't even know. The writing style is so wonderfully Whovian and whimsical in a way I can't describe. The way you've integrated this into the DW universe so seamlessly - "bleeding heart Doctor", ahaha, Sherlock, you superior bastard! All the little details, and the adorable dialogue, and... just everything, everything about this is amazing. You are amazing.

(So are the previous incarnations of The Detective, you know, the previous incarnations of SH? Granada!Holmes, 2009!Holmes, etc...)

Reply

Re: best homework break ever? i think so seaweedie April 11 2011, 09:22:27 UTC
ALSO IS THERE GOING TO BE A CONTINUATION
PLEASE DO A CONTINUATION BECAUSE THAT WOULD BE INDESCRIBABLY WONDERFUL

Reply

Re: best homework break ever? i think so lotherington April 11 2011, 13:01:08 UTC
You are SO SWEET! Thank you so, so much for all your lovely comments, I'm just thrilled that you enjoyed it as much as you did! You've made my day. :D

Sherlock is a ridiculously superior bastard, but that's why we love him! Having the previous SH incarnations as 1st, 2nd, 3rd Detective etc. is GENIUS, if I continue this and there's a way to work it in, may I use your idea? Obviously you will be credited, but that's just such a brilliant idea, haha! If I was better at graphics I'd be so tempted to create something based on this.

I have a few ideas that are begging me to write them (Mycroft on the High Council of Time Lords being one, haha), so a continuation may well happen!

Again, thank you so much for commenting! <3<3<3

Reply


introductory April 11 2011, 09:02:55 UTC
Oh my god.

Oh my god.

I just. *clutches heart* All the parallels to "The Eleventh Hour" and John's tea skills and Sherlock's psychic paper and just oh my god I can't even articulate how incredibly wondrous this is. I'm blinking away literal tears and I don't even know how they got there. This is beautiful.

Reply

lotherington April 11 2011, 13:04:47 UTC
Oh, thank you so much, this is one of the nicest comments I've ever received! I'm thrilled you enjoyed this and I'm really sorry about the tears! <3

Reply


ununpentium April 11 2011, 09:05:42 UTC
This is absolutely wonderful!

Reply

lotherington April 11 2011, 13:05:07 UTC
Thank you very much!

Reply


nox_candida April 11 2011, 09:08:50 UTC
What they all said, up there.

This is FANTASTIC! I'm usually more a fan of John being the Time Lord, but you absolutely made this work. I think this is the best Doctor Who fusion I've ever read, it's simply marvelous. I don't have enough words, enough superlatives to describe how much I adore this fic. Just, bravo. Absolutely fantastic, brilliant, amazing!

*going back to read it again*

Reply

lotherington April 11 2011, 13:06:23 UTC
Eee, thank you so much! I've never read a Time Lord!John fic, I might have to go and seek some out. I'm really pleased you enjoyed this, I loved writing it! <3

Reply

genclay April 12 2011, 10:57:10 UTC
Time lord John?

Could you please point me in the direction of this?

Reply

nox_candida April 12 2011, 21:02:41 UTC
Certainly!

Probably the best and most complete one I've read is Mislaid Memories by mr_x_indeed. Parts One, Two, Three and Four.

There's also two minifills here and here where John is a fob!watched Doctor and Sherlock is the Master.

There are also a couple of in-progress stories where John is fob!watched. Something Remembered by jade_starlight deals with John remembering the Pandorica, and Are You Now or Have You Ever Been by stardustgrl is John fob!watched and Harry as his companion.

I feel like there may have been one or two others that I'm missing one or two. For some reason, I thought there were more than there seem to be. There are a number of good Doctor Who/Sherlock crossovers, but these are specifically John as a Time Lord (and/or the Doctor). Enjoy. :)

Reply


nausicaa83 April 11 2011, 09:09:40 UTC
I loved this!!! Please, tell me there are going to be more chapters!!! ♥

Reply

lotherington April 11 2011, 13:07:09 UTC
Thank you so much, I'm so glad you enjoyed this! I'm not going to promise anything, but a continuation of some sort might well happen. :)

Reply

lotherington April 11 2011, 13:07:36 UTC
Oh, and I LOVE your icon!

Reply

nausicaa83 April 11 2011, 13:09:39 UTC
It was made by scarletwas, definitely my favourite crossover. *________*

Reply


Leave a comment

Up