The setting is in Nottingham Castle, England, in 1196 during a siege. A character receives a slash to the side, just below the ribs, with a sword and has a dagger thrust into the back of his shoulder nearly simultaneously. Is it possible to survive an attack like this and if so how would the wounds be treated? What would the damage be
(
Read more... )
Comments 5
Reply
Reply
http://en.allexperts.com/q/First-Aid-995/2010/10/Stab-wound-shoulder.htm
Some of this is pretty applicable. I'd say, based on that and removing the modern surgical stuff, that it may be the worst of the two wounds. A lot of permanent damage there that mediaeval surgeons probably wouldn't be able to treat.
Of course there is a lot of bone around the shoulder too, so if you wanted it superficial(ish) you could just say it hit the bone and skittered off. Be a nasty wound still, and prone to infection, but would be survivable with not much worse than a nasty scar. You can play the shoulder one either way depending on what you need.
I agree though, more info would be helpful.
Reply
On the other hand, serious gut wounds in a pre-modern era are generally fatal. If your character avoids slowly bleeding to death, having fatal damage to internal organs, or dying of infection (either from punctured intestines or from external contamination of the wound), he might live. If so, it's a combination of an iron constitution and sheer luck, and everyone will be extremely surprised. Treatment is likely to be focused on keeping the character comfortable, because everyone will assume he's going to die.
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment