Rate Breaking Dawn Part 1

[peggababy]

Poll

Comments

[tripmeup]

I honestly thought it was the worst and it definitely did not need to be split up into two parts. A whole bunch of nothing happens. Eclipse is hands down my favorite.

[irunthis2011]

ITA the book has three seperate parts.. the movie would be rediculously long is they tried to fit it all into one part.

[sunlight_23]

I completely disagree that nothing happens.
Bella experiences marriage, sex, impending motherhood, mortal death and transformation all in one film.
There's no way this could've been 1 film with Part 2 (unless it was a VERY long film) because the second film will obviously cover Bella's experience as a vampire and as a wife and mother.

Yes, some scenes dragged. But I would choose all of the Edward/Bella romance in BD Part 1 over NM/Eclipse action anyday.

[coquettes]

I'd say it's the best. The cringe-worthy moments were at their lowest, and the acting was the best in this movie.

[writing_memoirs]

I agree.

[kiwi096]

This. :)

[asian_soul]

it was the best. it's the first time i've cried in Twilight movies. omg...

[sunlight_23]

I don't know how anyone could say this is the worst and actually mean it.

I'm not crazy about the wolf parts or the length of the J/B dance, but the E/B scenes are beautiful, emotional and generally well-developed.

Layered performances from Rob/Kristen and wonderful chemistry between them.

I love BD's visual references to Twilight, which was my initial favorite of the films. Other scenes are also visually striking, such as Bella's nightmare and the birth scene.

I really don't like the emphasis on action in the 2nd/3rd films. It felt like the romance (EB's relationship) played second fiddle.

Imo the story of BD, with Bella taking a huge physical and emotional journey towards her transformation, translated very well to the screen.

[bcain1992]

A+ Comment. I totally agree.

[coquettes]

Yeah saying it was the worst one is a little too much. Everyone knows New Moon was the worst by far.

[fanatica87]

I laughed when I read your comment, but it makes me sad because it's true. New Moon IS the worst.

[lizlove07]

I honestly thought it was the best one (andnotjustbecausetherewasnoridiculousyoushouldhavepuppieswithjacobtalk)

It was the closest to the book, and I found that the essence of Edward/Bella was kept pretty intact, apart from the uber long Jacob/Bella dance but other than that I loved every minute of it.

[xmftf]

OT!..BUT OH MY GOD!! BONESSSSSSSSS :P