I was just going to post this. A friend of mine had this very conversation last year after she read Breaking Dawn. We both agreed Carlie would have been the perfect name.
I would have loved Renesmee to be called Elizabeth. Elizabeth Masen was such an important part of Edward's human life - she sacrificed her own life for his. And since Breaking Dawn is all about Bella attempting to sacrifice herself for her child, it would be a nice way to draw a parallel between Elizabeth Masen and Bella.
As for if it was a boy, I chose Other. I would have wanted them to call their child "Charles/Charlie". Because Carlisle and Edward and Jacob will live forever, but Bella's father won't, and it would be a lovely way to remember him.
Comments 85
Just vote for the first boy poll.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Also sub consciously if it wasn't for her, Edward would have never been a vampire and had never met Bella, so it could be like a thank you present.
Also Elizabeth will never know her granddaughter.
Reply
Reply
Reply
As for if it was a boy, I chose Other. I would have wanted them to call their child "Charles/Charlie". Because Carlisle and Edward and Jacob will live forever, but Bella's father won't, and it would be a lovely way to remember him.
Reply
Well nearly.
Reply
ia, if it wasn't for Elizabeth, Renesmee wouldn't even exist. And just because Elizabeth is a pretty name.
Reply
Elizabeth is a really pretty name and it's quite old fashioned like Edward.
Also they can call her Lizzy, my aunty is called Elizabeth and we always call her Aunty Lizzy.
Reply
Leave a comment