R7CH1 - voting

Aug 16, 2014 15:02


Voting
Challenge 1

The following chose to use a skip or failed to submit an icon so a skip has been used for them:

slytheringurrl (1)
reebeecaa (1)
mermaidskull (0)
moony_blues (1)
Vote here )

-voting, round 7

Leave a comment

Comments 8

bangel_4e August 16 2014, 12:08:27 UTC
r07ch01 Voting
One Lesser Quality
3 - You can't really make out the subject's face, as it's very shadowed and dark. Maybe a hint of light to underline his face features would've brought him out more.

One Better Quality
# -2

Reply


novindalf August 16 2014, 12:52:25 UTC
r07ch01 Voting
One Lesser Quality
#5 - The colours are nice, but the textures use make it look very grainy and LQ.

One Better Quality
#1 - Nice lighting and blocking

Reply


raktajinos August 16 2014, 15:55:54 UTC
r07ch01 Voting
One Lesser Quality
4 - the crop is excellent, but I think the icon would have benefited from having some contrast and shadow-contouring to help create dimension in the icon.

One Better Quality
2 - gorgeous crop and I love the muted colouring you enhanced

Reply


bloodstream7 August 16 2014, 20:16:33 UTC
r07ch01 Voting
One Lesser Quality
#4 - The icon needs more contrast. The light texture on the right side seems unnecessary to me (or it could have been stretched out to cover a bigger part of her face, of course only lightly). I can't figure out if it's because of the close crop or the colouring but the image looks a bit low quality.

One Better Quality
#2 - The crop is interesting and I think the muted colouring suits the screencap well.

Reply


marcasite August 16 2014, 21:08:08 UTC
r07ch01 Voting
One Lesser Quality
#05 - I love the use of color in this icon but it looks a little over saturated; the light streak on her face and red on her lips. Pretty crop though on this icon.

One Better Quality
#01 - love the creative use of screencaps

Reply


Leave a comment

Up