CHALLENGE #5 | VOTING

[neatmonster]

The following failed to enter and had no skips left, therefore they have been eliminated:

sucksucksmile

Comments

[novindalf]

1 lesser quality:
2 - It's certainly an original way of interpreting the screencap, but the triangle in the background looks very out of place and the icon is a bit too over-bright

1 favorite:
5 - Lovely colouring and use of textures

[arbdhax]

1 lesser quality:
1 - (reason): it looks that it needs a little bit more of the effect to see a good contrast on the icon, and the text makes a noise on the icon

1 favorite:
2 - (reason optional but nice)

[alfiri]

1 lesser quality:
6 - The texture does not add to the icon, it rather takes away from the subjects, especially the red does not fit with the rest of the icon (maybe try to make the texture black&white so that it's not overpowering).

1 favorite:
1 - I like the crop and the moody feel of the icon, the text works rather well also!

[lady_kingsley]

1 lesser quality:
1 - icon looks to dark, the contrast between Bellatrix's face and hair a bit too small, also the font doesn't match - it could be either lighter (to make it read easier) and.or placement changed.

1 favorite:
5 - Beautiful texture usage, coloring fits really nicely and everything is matching here perfectly.

[crazycordy]

1 lesser quality:
3 - The coloring is nice but the light texture seems out of place and is a bit distracting.

1 favorite:
6