CHALLENGE #5 | VOTING

[neatmonster]

The following chose to use a skip or didn't enter an icon so a skip has been used for them:
novindalf (1)
derniers_vers (0)

Comments

[afastmachine]

Goodness, I feel like I'm just gonna get voted out again!

1 lesser quality:
2 - I feel like the three different colors all kind of clash with each other, especially the gold of her headpiece and the deeper magenta of the rest of Diana. The lesser saturation of Steve on top of it also feels a bit incongruous.

1 favorite:
3 - it's so hard to do vibrant coloring with POC and not mess up their skin and you did an excellent job!

[naginis]

1 lesser quality:
1 - Not a bad icon at all, but his face seems a bit washed out, it's hard to make it out. Idk if it's the coloring, but maybe some more contrast could help.

1 favorite:
3

[scarred_loretta]

1 lesser quality:
4 - (Nit-picking a lot here) The icon looks very bright and sharp in places, eg on the right of the subject's head and arm. I like the background text texture but feel like it draws my attention even more so to the over-sharpness.

1 favorite:
1

[alfiri]

1 lesser quality:
4 - the text texture in the background takes away from the focus of the icon and the white of the text does not really compliment the rest of the colouring

1 favorite:
2 - love the composition and the gold detail in the background

[alwaysashipper]

1 lesser quality:
1 - the coloring is too muted.

1 favorite:
4 - great coloring and composition.

[neatmonster]

Can you expand on your lesser quality vote? Why is that a bad thing?

[alwaysashipper]

Sure, there's not enough contrast between the character and the background and they blend in too much. It's honestly a difficult choice because they're all so pretty! Iincluding the "lesser quality" one.