Round 4: Challenge 3, results

Jun 26, 2009 22:38

Unfortunately we have to say bye to a wonderful icon maker...

Results + Tally )

results, challenge 3, round 4

Leave a comment

Comments 10

nyaza June 26 2009, 20:51:35 UTC
Oh, may i have comments for #1?

Reply

ch4ndler July 14 2009, 09:31:40 UTC
+ Nice creativity. Cute choice of picture and good use of texture and black and white coloring
+ Amazing use of texture
- the textures used are good but the icon is a little too bright
+ The coloured textures works well with the black and white image. The cropping also works very well with the image.
+ good use of texture.
- texture doesnt really fit with the icon
- It's nice but the light texture looks a bit out of place

Reply


thedreamygirl June 26 2009, 21:24:12 UTC
May I have the comments for #7 please? :)

Reply

ch4ndler July 14 2009, 09:34:30 UTC
+ Really great coloring and nice choice of picture for the challenge
- The light texture makes the icon look blurry. It is misplaced
+ Simple yet effective
+ I love the cropping & light texture. The picture you chose is unique too :)

Reply


stam_fan17 June 26 2009, 22:09:41 UTC
aww it's okay (:
Comments for number 5 please ^-^

Reply

ch4ndler July 14 2009, 09:35:52 UTC
- The coloring is too red
- The picture is not sharp enough, which makes the icon a bit blurry. Also, the selective coloring is too overpowering. Perhaps lower some of the red settings?
- there's nothing special about it
- the image quality is poor and the text font doesn't compliment the screencap well
- The placement of the text doesn't fit the icon
- a little to plain compared to the other icons
- It's lovely, but compared to the others it's a bit plain

Reply


autumnleaves23 June 26 2009, 22:30:57 UTC
May I have the comments for #6?

Reply

ch4ndler July 14 2009, 09:37:26 UTC
+ Nice composition
- The blending cold be better/sharper & the yellow texture isn't the best contrast wise
+ the use of negative space is brilliant
- The texture used for the background doesn't blend well with the image

Reply


aniexx June 26 2009, 23:09:40 UTC
gee thanks!!!
comments for #2 please??

Reply

ch4ndler July 14 2009, 09:38:45 UTC
+ Nice cropping and coloring
+ Great crop & color
+ The croping works well with the subjects in the image. Also colouring is perfect
+ gorgeous colouring and great crop

Reply


Leave a comment

Up