Round 4: Challenge 2, results

Jun 09, 2009 21:31

Unfortunately we have to say bye to 2 wonderful icon makers...

Results + Tally )

results, round 4, challenge 2

Leave a comment

Comments 15

neatmonster June 10 2009, 16:35:12 UTC
comments for 4 please?

Reply

ch4ndler June 11 2009, 20:08:16 UTC
- too plain; the text is choppy-like
- text is awkward, coloring is washed out, crop is unoriginal

Reply


twiilightzone June 10 2009, 20:15:32 UTC
Comments for #10 please^^

Reply

ch4ndler June 11 2009, 20:09:30 UTC
+ just lovely use of texture and text
great work on the texture and text placement. as a personal opinion, it would work even better if colouring of image and texture where more closely in range (or if the image was b&w in the worst case). But it works well anyway.
+ Great use of texture and text

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

ch4ndler June 11 2009, 20:13:41 UTC
- Colouring looks washed up, it would be nice to have it be more strong and contrast would be a good way to do that. Also, text just doesn't fit the image: colour, size, placemente, it doesn't look like part of the icon
+i love the simplicty of the icon
- coloring is very washed out, text awkward

Reply


Leave a comment

Up