Week 16: Reinventing the Wheel

Feb 27, 2012 20:22

The day’s assignment loomed over my head: Draw an angel. Why did it have to be angels ( Read more... )

lj idol: fiction, lj idol: entries

Leave a comment

Comments 20

pixiebelle February 28 2012, 04:20:14 UTC
That was wrong of the art teacher to not encourage your creativity. How sad that he did that to you!

Oops. It's fiction? My bad :P

Reply

lilycobalt February 28 2012, 04:41:53 UTC
Sadly, I did not possess this level of self-confidence as a teenager. Though it teeters on arrogance, so perhaps that's okay after all. I'm glad that it was believable as a kid in an art class, though!

Reply


serpentpixie February 28 2012, 13:03:24 UTC
This is something that actually does happen in art classes, and a lot of teachers completely fail to define the difference between producing work to a commission (when you absolutely have to meet the brief) and producing work as an organic evolution of a prompt/theme/starting point. As a student it can be unbearably frustrating - I've definitely been there, with a teacher who just said "you can't do that" and I said "why?" and the teacher says, "because I say so".

I would say, though, that 99.9% of students are not so arrogant as to say I was a true genius, even if this teacher refused to see it - and I find it frustrating that these words often get put into their mouths - people who deem themselves "geniuses" tend to refuse to self-improve, and most creative people question things and disagree vocally with things in a quest to improve themselves and their practice. Sometimes this means disagreeing with a teacher (or, indeed, a peer), and that's OK. That putting-of-words-into-mouths is kind of frustrating, because it perpetuates the ( ... )

Reply

lilycobalt March 4 2012, 05:10:02 UTC
I'm sure it does happen a lot, and I'm lucky that it didn't happen to me. I did go into caricature to a certain extent here, so thanks for highlighting that important middle ground.

Reply


pricelessone February 28 2012, 14:27:03 UTC
"Nobody's ever seen an angel. So I drew myself looking for one," spoke to me very deeply. Great work.

Reply

lilycobalt March 4 2012, 05:10:11 UTC
Thanks a lot!

Reply


xo_kizzy_xo February 28 2012, 23:05:01 UTC
For all we know, angels probably don't look anything like the way our culture envisions them, so in that sense, you were perfectly justified :)

Reply

lilycobalt March 4 2012, 05:10:39 UTC
They probably don't. I certainly have no way of knowing, and neither did my character.

Reply


java_fiend February 29 2012, 02:24:20 UTC
Wow... shouldn't your personal beliefs help inform your art? I think the instructor was dead wrong in calling you out like that. What an idiot.

Reply

lilycobalt March 4 2012, 05:11:00 UTC
I think so! Fictional instructor is closed-minded.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up