R2:W9 RESULTS!

Nov 09, 2008 10:32

Leave a comment

Comments 5

bossygenius November 9 2008, 16:21:58 UTC
Thank you! :D

Can I see the comments for #3, please?

Reply

stolenwings November 9 2008, 16:37:08 UTC
-
bad use of texture, poor colouring.

+
nice crop and color.
great coloring and use of textures.
very good composition and colouring. the icon is so soft.
the back coloring brings out leighton's dress and face.

Reply


stylespook November 9 2008, 17:01:26 UTC
thank you for the mod's choice :)
and comments for 2?

Reply

stolenwings November 9 2008, 17:22:43 UTC
i love your entry. i was shocked at the number of negative votes.

-
its too faded and you can't see her face.
the coloring is too desaturated, it almost looks as if the opacity was turned down a bit.
the coloring is washed out.
the icon looks washed out and too light.

+
great composition, great colouring.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

stolenwings November 10 2008, 22:04:42 UTC
+
its very original and the colors are pretty.

-
I think the icon's composition wasn't executed well--it just looks unfinished.
the icon seems just off and too crowded. the idea is nice, but the red and blue pictures look washed out and lack a bit of contrast.
i couldnt see leighton's face anymore, the color combination is distracting.
all the colors are very distracting.
i think this would work better if the white squares were filled or seomthing. it looks like its missing something.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up