round four; challenge seven; voting

Sep 10, 2010 21:54

Eliminated;
(failed to submit an icon)

Skipping;
(with valid excuse)

Rules/Forms/Entries )

round four, r4:ch07, voting

Leave a comment

Comments 8

chosenfire28 September 11 2010, 03:30:26 UTC
Negative Votes
(-2 points): #06 - The text isn't really readable, a different color or font would have made it easy to read but as it is you can't.
(-1 points): #02 - The image could be lighter and the text doesn't really fit.

Positive Votes
(+2 points): #05 - The coloring and text of this icon are beautiful and go together perfectly!.
(+1 points): #04 - The coloring on the icon is beautiful and the image is clear and smooth.

Reply


sourpony September 11 2010, 04:34:50 UTC
Negative Votes
(-2 points): #06 - The text is unnecessary and hard to read to read. It distracts from the unique shading.
(-1 points): #05 - The text does not match the icon and the coloring on her face is very harsh.

Positive Votes
(+2 points): #01 - Gorgeous coloring.
(+1 points): #02 - I love the crop and the coloring; just a tad dark in places but adds to the mood.

Reply


sallyna_smile September 11 2010, 09:28:37 UTC
Negative Votes
(-2 points): #08 - the colors aren't defined enough, too much white spots.
(-1 points): #03 - there should be more saturation of colors.

Positive Votes
(+2 points): #07 love the composition.
(+1 points): #02

Reply


syxstring September 11 2010, 22:24:25 UTC
Negative Votes
(-2 points): #03 - The icon lacks contrast.
(-1 points): #06 - The text really doesn't fit the icon and is hard to read.

Positive Votes
(+2 points): #01 - Beautiful composition.
(+1 points): #05

Reply


lynzie914 September 12 2010, 03:06:32 UTC
Negative Votes
(-2 points): #06 - The text is difficult to read, I can't make out what exactly its saying. .
(-1 points): #04 - The background is too bright, it overwhelms the icon.

Positive Votes
(+2 points): #07 - Very good use of negative space and coloring.
(+1 points): #03 -unusual cropping.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up