Comments | lantis_lims: Round 3 // Challenge 17 Results

shadowserenity in lantis_lims

Round 3 // Challenge 17 Results

Feb 14, 2008 06:55

Voting was so very tight this week.

Members' Choice and Mod's Choice winner banner maker for this challenge is azangal_icons.

( Challenge 17 Results )

results, round three, challenge seventeen

Comments 10

elli February 13 2008, 21:12:37 UTC

Unscreend is fine. Mine is number 6.

shadowserenity February 13 2008, 21:20:12 UTC

- her head is cut off. Maybe I am missing something, maybe it is artistic, maybe I just don't get it, but, I repeat, her head is cut off.
- why did you sever Elizabeth's head? It kinda kills the icon a bit.
- The set up of this icon is really well done - it's creativity and works with the background coloring, which I love.
- Love the coloring - it's subdued, but just masterful. And the text! And all of it! It's awesome. I want it. :p

elli February 13 2008, 21:25:17 UTC

Rofl! The head is cut of on purpose to symbolize the loss Alantis has suffered with Elizabeths death. Or maybe I just think it's pretty *g*

And go ahead and snag. I have one where she HAS a head as well!

animotus February 13 2008, 21:26:09 UTC

Well...as always I've loved being part of this lims!And I really didn't expect to be still here!See you in the next round!;)
Comments for 2 unscreened,thank you!

shadowserenity March 8 2008, 13:03:59 UTC

So sorry for the delay!

Yes, next round! Glad to hear you'll be back :D.

- It immediately caught my attention. I love the color, the border and the cropping.
- The cropping is off - Weir is so small compared to the rest of the space, and the bright yellow doesn't work with her coloring.
- I'm not entirely sure what the intent behind the border was, but it detracts from the icon on whole. The bright coloring and type don't mesh very well either.
- Weir herself is a bit too sharp around the edges but too blurry and not clear over the rest, and the background is a bit messy with texture. The text also sticks out and doesn't really blend with the icon well.
- Elizabeth doesn't blend well with background; Elizabeth is too small, especially since you've cropped off her shoulders; border distracts too much (especially given it only appears on three sides).

paperbinned February 13 2008, 22:10:11 UTC

Sheesh, that was tight. Comments for #4 please, unscreened is fine. :)

shadowserenity March 8 2008, 13:05:11 UTC

So sorry for the delay!

- text is too blurry
- really brilliant correlation between a sports ad and that image and it is clear and bright with good text
- [The blending is a little sharp and the text is partly blurry, I'm not sure if the text part is intentional but it makes the rest of the icon look sharp]
- But it's so pretteh! Nice composition, too.
- I love it! Coloring, cropping, clarity, text, all done fabulously!

emily_reich February 14 2008, 09:54:06 UTC

whoa, tight voting indeed! i can't believe absolutely everyone got negative votes and positive votes! maybe i just haven't been around lims long enough :p

anyway, comments for #1, please... unscreened is fine

shadowserenity March 8 2008, 13:06:25 UTC

So sorry for the delay!

- Absolutely amazing. Such a gorgeous icon.
- I don't like the crop, it's not very original.
- lovely; really pretty.

newkidfan February 14 2008, 17:55:19 UTC

5, screened and thank you!