Round 3 // Challenge 15 Results

[shadowserenity]

Sorry for the delay, folks.

Members' Choice and Mod's Choice winner banner maker for this challenge is agentcat47.

Comments

[animotus]

Wow,thank you very much for the Mod's choice!♥
Comments for #4 unscreened,thanks!

[shadowserenity]

- a little sharp, but the colouring and text and crop are fantastic
- I really like this, the coloring, the cropping, the placement of the text, very nicely done.
- Colour :O
- [It seems a little saturated and the text is awkwardly placed making it hard to read.]
- This icon really pops - the coloring is beautifully done, too. It's a lot of pink, but it oddly works for me.
- I bet I know who made this one...but I won't say cuz I was wrong last time, LOL. Why is a centered picture so pretty? Pretty in pink...
- hot pink for the win! love the text, as well, with the 'brave' in pink over the paler area, and the rest of the text white, and interesting cropping of Rodney. just very interesting to look at.

[paperbinned]

Ouch. Haha, ah well, I had a feeling. Comments for #2, please. Unscreened is fine. :)

[shadowserenity]

- like the rounded edges, but the colouring and crop could be better
- I like the rounded edges but the coloring is overwhelmingly orange and there are blocks of color on their faces.
- there seems to be a shift in the color-balance, good. The rounded corners is a good one. Unfortunately it looks a little plain, a little simplistic.
- The orange bleeds into the faces a bit much--giving them an odd skintone.
- The rounded edges kind of detract from the icon, strangely. The coloring is rather dark as well. Not a bad icon, but there's something a little too simple about it.
- Good colouring and compostition
- Love the colors! Rounded corners are often strange but they really work for this icon.
- while I like the rounded corners and the crop, I feel the icon is a little too dark and could do with more influential colouring.

[emily_reich]

holy crap I'm still here :p I kinda thought for sure I was gonna be out this time :p

comments for #3 please? unscreened is fine.

[shadowserenity]

- too sharp
- The contrast is really nice.
- I like the cropping and the selective use of color
- Love the little bit of colour on top.
- The image is over-sharpened, and the colour spots really aren't adding anything.

[ctofine]

Would love to see my comments, thanks! #8...public is fine. :)

[shadowserenity]

- the texture and text doesn't work well with the icon

[ctofine]

Thanks for the info! I've enjoyed the LIMS. And, ironically *points at comments* I used no texture in this icon...that's the actual FLOOR from the cap! LOL Thanks again!

[newkidfan]

Oh! #7, screened, please and thank you!