Round 3 // Challenge 9 Results

[shadowserenity]

Sorry for the delay, folks.

Members' Choice and Mod's Choice winner banner maker for this challenge is thisissirius.

Comments

[meganlynn09]

Darn, I knew I should have submitted that other icon. Oh well, it was a terrible week for voting as ALL the entries were so fantastic.

I'd like comments on #7, thanks :D Unscreened is fine.

[shadowserenity]

Thanks so much for participating in this round! You're always a star :).

- The texture is a little bit sharp and the colouring too brown.
- It's a little dark, and the cropping feels, well, off... the off-center just doesn't feel right with the image blend used.
- needs brightening.
- Placement of the figure are a little plain. The colors could be more vivid, particularly for the choice of cropping.

[shadowserenity]

- Icon could use more depth of colour and shadow. Her face is a bit blurred by the white.
- The textures are overpowering and seem out of place.
- the background is too distracting and takes attention away from teyla
- Lovely colouring and use of texture, a very pretty icon.

[anonymous]

& he's so delicious, unscreened pls

[prettybutt]

signing in helps, #2

[shadowserenity]

- hee! so cute!; I love your take on such an overused image; fantastic positioning of the Hewlett and the text (the text especially because that is so difficult to fit on either side of the figure!).
- Excellent text placement, good colouring... And it just makes me happy.
- This made me laugh out loud; I could not love it more if I tried.
- I must admit, if there's a deeper meaning to the text, I don't get it... but it's done just perfectly! and the coloring, cropping, and composition are great!
- The text is cute and funny and the pink/purple coloring supports the cuteness.
- I dunno if there's some in-joke associated with this, but it still made me snicker. :)
- Too cute for words!!! I love the text placement and the pink fits great.

[paperbinned]

#5, s'il vous plaît. Unscreened, is cool. :)

[shadowserenity]

- I love the composition on this, especially with the added touch of the branches.
- Love the blending of the images and great coloring
- the composition is just awesome.
- This has to be the weirdest, coolest icon I have ever seen. He's climbing up her face! I mean...WHOA!
- It looks like Ronon is climbing Teyla's face. Which is disconcerting. I feel like the icon is telling a story I don't understand.

[scifijunkie]

#13, please. Unscreened is fine.

[shadowserenity]

- I love the cropping on this, the black and white, the way the inset picture is the reverse of the larger image.