Round 3 // Challenge 7 Results

[shadowserenity]

Members' Choice and Mod's Choice winner banner maker for this challenge is abernathi.

Comments

[animotus]

Comments for 11 unscreened,thanks.

[shadowserenity]

- John's skin is too saturated with red/purple. It's really not flattering for this icon or for him. As a whole, the colours are too harsh.

[shadowserenity]

- I adore the composition of this icon. It really changes up the original picture.
- the green things (smudgy leaves?) are covering J too much, hard to figure out what they are
- The weird brown coloring is shaped oddly and does nothing for the icon.
- I can't really explain why I like this icon. It's interesting and the cropping is cool and the coloring (the differences between light and dark) are different. I like it.
- Nice composition. The coloring is humble but striking.

[ex_spiffyda]

Comments for #21 please, unscreened is fine :)

[shadowserenity]

- [I love the coloring]
- The colours in this icon are just gorgeous. Wonderful work.
- great use of texture and color
- The coloring is a bit too overexposed and it makes the icon look grainy.
- on my screen, blue pixellated lines show up through Teyla's hair reducing the image quality; blue curves function pushed up too high.
- The colors are blotchy and pixelated. Teyla is too saturated; her skin is an odd color.

[agentcat47]

comments for 7 please. thank you! screened, also. :)

[silentsarah]

[shadowserenity]

Hey, thanks for participating :).

- Way too washed out.
- The faded coloring on the icon detracts from the detail of the picture.
- Liz on the image is too faded and coloring leaves more to be desired.
- The light textures hide Elizabeth.
- little contrast
- A bit too pink, too many glowy balls...doesn't really compliment.
- It's too bright, washes Weir out too much.
- The icon is really pale/washed out and lacking in contrast, such that the colors feel flat and the icon feels unfocused.