Round 2 // Challenge 15 Voting

[shadowserenity]

Thank you for getting your sets in so quickly! :) For voting, I've decided to mash all your icons together, have people vote in the usual way (except with more Fs and LFs), then put the points together to determine who'll go through to the final round. That way each icon will be judged individually - one icon can bring your set down and another can lead you to a win; it's all about overall quality of your set. I will showcase your sets in full after voting. If you have any questions, you know I'm here to answer them :).

You must vote for four icons: your four (4) least favourite (the entries you consider to be of lesser quality in technique) and your four (4) favourite (the entries you consider to be the best). You must provide a reason for your former vote (providing a reason for your latter vote is optional, but strongly encouraged). Please remember that you are judging on technique, not personal preference. Reasons such as "I dislike this character and I can't believe you used my least favourite colour for your background" are not acceptable.

Example voting format:

LF:
[icon number] - [reason mandatory]
[icon number] - [reason mandatory]
[icon number] - [reason mandatory]
[icon number] - [reason mandatory]

F:
[icon number] - [reason optional]
[icon number] - [reason optional]
[icon number] - [reason optional]
[icon number] - [reason optional]

Note: LF first please. You'll make me stumble if you put F before LF.

For a further look at the voting rules, see lantis's user info. Please remember anyone can vote. Comments are screened.



1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

Voting concludes Tuesday, September 4th, 11PM EST.