Round 5 // Challenge 9 Results

Aug 07, 2009 16:45

Members' Choice and Mod's Choice winner banner maker for this challenge is my_tourniquet13.

Challenge 9 Results )

results, round five, challenge nine

Leave a comment

Comments 14

meganlynn09 August 7 2009, 13:17:21 UTC
Woah, awesome, thanks, you guys!

Comments for #6, please? Unscreened is fine :)

Reply

shadowserenity August 7 2009, 15:07:14 UTC
(I thought your icon was really nice :))

- nice coloring and placement
- the colour balance is beautiful, the image placement, size and cropping are perfect.
- [i love the simplicity of the icon, the coloring is perfect and the background is calm enough to make ronon pop out]
- great use of negative space, it compliments his lonesome warrior attitude in this cap.
- [Cropping and color are fantastic.]
- Oversharpened and the edges are pixelated.
- i like the way the background draws your eyes in to the middle of the icon (and ronon). very nicely composed
- lovely positioning of Ronon and use of colours in substituted background.

Reply


beeej August 7 2009, 15:28:21 UTC
Comments for #11, please. Thanks!

Reply

shadowserenity August 17 2009, 17:48:29 UTC
Sorry for the delay!

- it's not a bad icon, but it's a bit blurry.
- Good mix of colors. Nice blending between background and foreground. Great lighting, good composition.
- lovely coloring and beautiful blending of texture; colors on the texture really enhance Teyla's coloring.
- I really like the background and how it complements and highlights Teyla

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

shadowserenity August 17 2009, 17:49:59 UTC
Sorry for the delay! And thanks so much for participating!

- the cut-out needs polishing up, especially around her hair and her right shoulder; background is a little dull.
- It looks like a really rough blend, it should look a little smoother around Elizabeth and maybe have a little less of the lighter textures.
- [a bit oversharpened and bright.]
- the cut-out needs more work, it's a bit blurry around her hair and there's still a dark line at her right side.
- The cutout seems a bit sloppy, especially on the right side (arm/shoulder) and around the nose and forehead.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up