Round 5 // Challenge 2 Results

May 30, 2009 17:10

Members' Choice and Mod's Choice winner banner maker for this challenge is alyburns.

Challenge 2 Results )

results, challenge two, round five

Leave a comment

Comments 36

azangal_icons May 30 2009, 07:26:56 UTC
#25 screened plz thnks

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

shadowserenity May 30 2009, 07:33:14 UTC
Btw, mine was #28 this week! I just couldn't come up with anything. I love your entry however :D.

- Love the way the colour of the texture echoes the colours in the clothing. Vibrant colouring. Overall an eye-catching icon.
- I love the "earthy" background; great image quality; good positioning of Elizabeth.

Reply


veronica_a May 30 2009, 08:53:21 UTC
Aww, thank you!!
Comments for #12, please?

Reply

shadowserenity May 30 2009, 23:53:52 UTC
- [It's such a beautiful icon! After all the icons had loaded it was the first one to catch my attention. It's bright and bold and it has an amazing use of textures]
- I liked how you moved John to Elizabeth's other side and added the background.
- the edges need to be cut more precisely, but i love the composition.
- lovely coloring, and I love how the green pops against the red of Elizabeth's shirt and how the shape of the clouds adds to the composition.
- The drama and coloration of the icon are appealing.
- Beautiful background replacement, the soft feel of the icon fits well
- [In this one, I think it's the positioning and coloring that caused the clouds to appear to be erupting out of Elizabeth's head. It's very disconcerting - takes away from the otherwise loveliness of what could have been an excellent icon]
- great colouring, characters stand out nicely.

Reply


crystal_lily May 30 2009, 11:06:38 UTC
Comments for #13, please? Unscreened is just fine. :D

Reply

shadowserenity May 30 2009, 23:55:08 UTC
- lovely and bright.
- [the simple coloring and cropping is beautiful]
- nice colour. good crop.

Reply


acari May 30 2009, 12:38:52 UTC
Huh, okay. It was fun while it lasted. Thanks for letting me play. Can I have comments for #18, unscreened is fine.

Just because I'm a bit confused. I thought the point of this challenge was to have three or more people in the frame, but I see a bunch of icons with two or less people. If I had known that, I'd have done something else.

Reply

shadowserenity May 30 2009, 23:59:25 UTC
I'm sorry you misinterpreted the challenge :(. The challenge blurb stated that the caps focused on three or more people in frame. Had the point of this challenge been to include them all in your icon, the blurb would have said something like "It is a requirement to include three or more people in your entry ( ... )

Reply

aliline June 2 2009, 12:25:40 UTC
ust because I'm a bit confused. I thought the point of this challenge was to have three or more people in the frame
I thought the same, so I didn't enter any icon because I couldn't do any good with that in mind. :(

Reply


Leave a comment

Up