Round 4 // Challenge 15 Results

Oct 08, 2008 01:04

Members' Choice and Mod's Choice winner banner maker for this challenge is firstanointed.

Challenge 15 Results )

challenge fifteen, results, round four

Leave a comment

Comments 19

shadowserenity October 7 2008, 15:12:37 UTC
Man, sorry to lose you guys. Hope you'll be back for the next round!

Reply


freneticfloetry October 7 2008, 15:15:48 UTC
It was the curse of the battle! I did call it, though. :) Much luck to everyone.

Not sure I want to see, but comments for 10, please? Unscreened is fine.

Reply

shadowserenity October 7 2008, 15:25:02 UTC
You so did call it! (And I must have you back in my greedy clutches for R5 'cause I love you ;))

- Text is too hard to read.
- the icon is unfortunately so dark and doesn't seem to pop. the colouring is a bit dull.
- The lighting on the icon is to much, tone it down a little.
- I really like the path that the eye travels in this icon and the colors are really gorgeous. I also like the ethereal quality of the text.
- I think the light texture is just too big and bold, and overshadows the image. Texture should enhance the image, rather than detract.
- The light texture kind of takes over the icon and interferes too much with the text.
- [A little heavy on the light blobs.]
- [The texture just takes over the whole icon. Without really looking at it you don't even notice the original cap.]

Reply

freneticfloetry October 7 2008, 15:53:05 UTC
All things I might've said, had you cleared me for voting against myself. Heh.

I'll look forward to R5. :)

Reply

darsynia October 7 2008, 18:11:54 UTC
I liked it! I'm sorry to see you go <3 (haha now you know whose was the positive feedback...)

Reply


elli October 7 2008, 15:36:47 UTC
screened please...7.

Reply


beeej October 7 2008, 20:13:52 UTC
Comments for #5, please. Unscreened is fine. Thanks!

Reply

shadowserenity October 8 2008, 06:18:54 UTC
- Great text and coloring.
- The texture went so well with this icon. Excellent job!! And yay, Toy story!! :D
- Stunning colors. Fun, crisp text.

Reply


sinfully_yours9 October 7 2008, 21:17:26 UTC
whew, close one! congrats to the winners!!

comments for 8, unscreened is just fine (:

Reply

shadowserenity October 8 2008, 06:20:12 UTC
- requires more contrast; too light.
- Like the crop and the vignetting, but there's not enough contrast.
- Image is too dark, not enough contrast.
- black and white images need good contrast, and this lacks that (though the concept itself is good).

Reply


Leave a comment

Up