Round 4 // Challenge 14 Results

Sep 29, 2008 18:03

Members' Choice and Mod's Choice winner banner maker for this challenge is clear_as_blood.

Challenge 14 Results )

results, challenge fourteen, round four

Leave a comment

Comments 11

(The comment has been removed)

darsynia September 29 2008, 19:56:26 UTC
Are you kidding? I loved that icon! It really stood out :)

Reply

shadowserenity September 30 2008, 04:42:21 UTC
- The clarity on this image is just astounding, and I love the crop.
- The simple, flattering coloring combined with a crop that adds emotion and character ends up making a composition that is very interesting as well as minimal. I like the clarity of the image, as well.
- Excellent crop
- Loving the crop and the coloring. Simple and elegant Teyla.
- gorgeous! the colouring is so pretty and fresh (very clean and sharp) and I adore the cropping!
- [Great cropping and coloring]
- the crop of the icon and the blank space works really well.
- The crop isn't flattering.
- The crop is static and there isn't much depth to the icon. It also appears unbalanced; some sort of text or decoration (even just a small stripe or line of a texture or brush) along the right would really liven it up.
- lovely soft colouring and interesting cropping; good choice replacing the background.

Reply


freneticfloetry September 29 2008, 16:01:49 UTC
Yay, both my votes! Congrats to all. :)

Reply


beeej September 29 2008, 16:52:47 UTC
Whew! I was worried. Comments for #2, please. Unscreened is fine, thanks!

Reply

shadowserenity September 30 2008, 04:43:52 UTC
- Blending doesn't really work and leaves the icon seeming almost incomplete
- the icon isn't blended. maybe making ronan black and white and faded out a little would work better.
- the blending of these two images is odd and unbalanced: the b&w of the city is too dark compared with ronon's brighter colouring.

Reply


elli September 29 2008, 19:00:08 UTC
13 screened please...

Reply


sinfully_yours9 September 30 2008, 03:12:57 UTC
Congrats to the winners!!!
Phew! -iz uber glad she made it through- I was a little worried. I mean, I liked my icon, but I wasn't sure how it would go over, the colouring was a little weird.
Ah, I digress--comments for number 9, please and thank you! unscreened is just fine (:

Reply

shadowserenity September 30 2008, 04:47:55 UTC
- Nice cropping and the smoky look on the icon is pretty
- Lovely crop, like the softness added by the brush/texture used
- You cant tell who the icon is of, and it's to dark

Reply


Leave a comment

Up