Comments | lady_ganesh: Someone remembers this. I know they do. (Yami no Questions!)

lady_ganesh

Someone remembers this. I know they do. (Yami no Questions!)

Feb 26, 2011 22:24

Because my manga is, um. Somewhere. Somewhere.

( Possibly triggery spoilers for Hisoka's death )

Comments 10

chibimazoku February 27 2011, 03:48:38 UTC

It's in Hisoka's file, so... I think you could argue Tatsumi knows? Because I wouldn't put it past him to look up ALL OF THE FILES.

lady_ganesh February 27 2011, 03:51:27 UTC

YES that seems likely. Do you remember what volume that's in?

chibimazoku February 27 2011, 16:02:28 UTC

The file stuff? It's in the first volume :Db

momebie February 27 2011, 04:19:50 UTC

Ugh. I have this series, but I don't begin to know where to look. Like, I want to think that they know towards the end (or towards where she left off, rather), but I'm not sure. HERM. THAT WIKI PAGE IS THE MOST USELESS WIKI PAGE. WHAT THE HECK, FANDOM?

lady_ganesh February 27 2011, 04:21:28 UTC

IKR? Five seconds after I posted (lol, my life) I remembered where they were but OMG SO MUCH MATERIAL SO LITTLE TO FIND. I did finally find the 'I know Muraki's alive' scene, which is just Hisoka and Tsuzuki. So...I'm not sure where else it might be. The original reveal is just with Tsuzuki, and they don't talk about it when Hisoka goes off to bathe at the hot springs by himself....

meganbmoore February 27 2011, 04:28:41 UTC

I HAVE NO IDEA WHERE MY MANGA IS, but, IIRC, I think they all acted like, if nothing else, they strongly suspected sexual abuse in his past? MAYBE I SHOULD FIND IT AND REREAD IT. Aside from the shelves of unread manga right over there, that is...

lady_ganesh February 27 2011, 04:32:11 UTC

At one point, and I don't remember if it made it to the translation or not, Tsuzuki ends up thinking 'maybe you were better off dead than in this fucked-up house, Kurosaki-kun.'

I'm pretty sure they know about the murder one way or another, less sure about the rape, and less sure than that about the curse.

heterodog February 27 2011, 16:59:05 UTC

Murder is def. in Hisoka's file and it is known that death wasn't immediate, so Tatsumi would have a pretty good idea of how it went, especially after learning Muraki is Hisoka's murderer.

p_zeitgeist February 27 2011, 20:08:20 UTC

I'm not sure it's really established. The Goushoshin know what's in his file, because they tell Tsuzuki to back off a little early in the series. And Hisoka may have succeeded in getting to his own confidential files; I don't think we're told whether his attempt is successful or not ( ... )

lady_ganesh February 27 2011, 20:18:07 UTC

(After all, Enma hints around late in the series about Muraki, or perhaps his grandfather, being in some way involved in Enma's grand and mysterious plans. Which suggests that matters involving him are going to be highly classified, to the extent that they can be.)

Oh yes, I'd forgotten that! PLAUSIBLE DENIABILITY: ACHIEVED.