Leave a comment

Comments 30

kansan_entrails October 16 2010, 01:59:54 UTC
The "YOU FAIL" icon is very appropriate. XD I have a fuck ton of icons...maybe I should post them. Or maybe not.

Reply

lady_ganesh October 16 2010, 02:50:59 UTC
It's fun! I...kind of forgot I had some of them.

Reply

kansan_entrails October 16 2010, 03:37:43 UTC
LOL Nice.

Reply

lady_ganesh October 24 2010, 18:05:24 UTC
This one is new...:D

Reply


robowolf October 16 2010, 02:03:21 UTC
I assumed "Yoko Ono" meant the "breaks up the band" kind of character, not the woman herself. Although having read up on John Lennon, I personally think Ono >>>>>>> Lennon.

Also, Uhura is so not useless. It's not her fault Shatner was such an attention hog that all the good stuff went to him or sometimes Nimoy and Kelly; nothing ever really gets to happen for any of the other main cast.

Reply

rosehiptea October 16 2010, 02:07:24 UTC
Also, Uhura is so not useless.

I was really ticked off to see her on that chart.

Not that I really bought into the chart in the first place.

Reply

robowolf October 16 2010, 02:15:08 UTC
If it were just a tropes chart, it'd be kinda spot on in a lot of places ("does she get an abortion?" --> "haha of course she doesn't" - SOB), but the part where she implies that all of these are not STRONG FEMALE CHARACTERS...conforming to a few tropes != not a strong character.

Also, Azula is sexualized? Um. And I don't know if I'd call the mom from Arrested Development a villain. It's not really a show with a villain...

Reply

rosehiptea October 16 2010, 02:31:08 UTC
Yeah, I think it's pretty clear that Azula is not sexualized.

I'm kind of wondering who is left over when you get rid of all the female characters who conform to tropes.

Reply


nina_vendredi October 16 2010, 02:18:32 UTC
I have an unfortunate lack of women in my icons. I believe I will fix that this weekend.

Reply

lady_ganesh October 16 2010, 02:55:47 UTC
I had more than I thought I would, which made me happy.

Reply


jaina October 16 2010, 02:27:05 UTC
I gave that chart a "lol no" when I saw Azula on there. Apparently she's not sufficiently layered and nuanced.

Reply

lady_ganesh October 16 2010, 02:56:23 UTC
And as I've said in other places, I think we should reserve "Hitler" as a descriptor for Hitler.

Reply

jaina October 16 2010, 02:56:58 UTC
A+ comment

Reply

lady_ganesh October 16 2010, 02:58:03 UTC
Newsflash: Genocide is not just the realm of German assholes!

Reply


gaisce October 16 2010, 02:34:53 UTC
I had a moment of confusion just looking at the flowchart and going "okay I can see how some of the tropes come off awkward but eh" and then I noticed it was apparently judging "one and two dimensional characters," countering any of the others listed were not strong female characters and I just. What. By what standard is this person basing it on, how they were formatted? Because that's the only way I can see them coming off. Otherwise why would you list Usagi, Ripley, Hit Girl, Harley Quinn, Azula, Dorothy from the blessed bastion of female awesome Golden Girls, Angelica, Faye Valentine--DO THEY EVEN KNOW HOW STUPIDLY COMPLICATED MYSTIQUE'S MOTIVES AND LOYALTIES ARE?

Do her fictional females need to be able to tesseract before they are qualified as worthy of being multidimensional?

Reply

lady_ganesh October 16 2010, 02:57:21 UTC
THERE WERE TWO GOLDEN GIRLS ON THERE did they ever watch the fucking SHOW?

Apparently! Backward and in heels....

Reply

gaisce October 16 2010, 03:09:45 UTC
Everything about this chart is awful. I didn't even notice how they included real women and the terms like Hitler and Noble S--word which is somehow more offensive than Savage. Ugh.

Urge to essay...rising...

Reply

lady_ganesh October 16 2010, 03:10:48 UTC
And they called an Asian girl 'vanilla'! SO CLASSY.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up