Comments | kristenb_lims: challenge 3 results

note_sarcasm in kristenb_lims

challenge 3 results

Jul 05, 2010 10:57

eliminated

( Read more... )

results

Comments 7

xoxoknlove July 5 2010, 01:36:16 UTC

comments for icon #6 please (:

note_sarcasm July 5 2010, 23:14:32 UTC

mods: I quite like this icon btw

REASONS
because the edges are oversharpened
The coloring is really good and the crop was a good choice.
Great colouring and cropping.

kateliciously July 5 2010, 18:09:23 UTC

Ahh... too bad. Can I see my comments(#7) please?

note_sarcasm July 5 2010, 23:29:32 UTC

-the blending is not well done
- because the color is a little washed out and the text is slightly hard to
read
- The crop makes the viewer hard to see who is in the icon
- The crop isn't the best choice, especially on the right side were the heads are kinda cut off. It doesn't work really well.

sorry to see you go

littleangel1987 July 5 2010, 19:13:47 UTC

#3, please :)

note_sarcasm July 5 2010, 23:31:12 UTC

+Great colouring
- the cut-out effect on the image is not done well

(The comment has been removed)

note_sarcasm July 10 2010, 22:37:15 UTC

+because the background and image blend well and the color is nice.
+The brownish coloring on Veronica works really good with the background and makes the icon kinda whole.