ficlet project: "Culloden" (Doctor Who)

Sep 23, 2010 19:41

Title: Culloden
Fandom: Doctor Who
Characters: Jamie McCrimmon, Second Doctor
Rating: All ages
Warnings: None needed
Word count: 100
Summary: History, truth, and entertainment.
Notes: Written for
Read more... )

fic: 2010, fic: drabbles, fic: doctor who, ficlet project

Leave a comment

Comments 6

stunt_muppet September 24 2010, 02:18:43 UTC
Doctor Who, Three/Delgado!Master, motifs

Reply


stunt_muppet September 24 2010, 02:22:01 UTC
And now for the actual commentary on the fic:

I really liked this. I loved the commentary on the way even rigorously researched portrayals are removed from the real thing, and the way we use real deaths as entertainment. And Jamie's reaction is spot-on, especially noticing the little details first.

Reply

kindkit September 24 2010, 05:31:35 UTC
Thank you!

I think I'm probably doing the film an injustice, in the sense that it was created in part as a critique of imperialism and an indirect response to the Vietnam War. But no historical re-enactment is ever going to be anything but disturbing for someone who was actually there.

Reply


wishfulaces September 24 2010, 02:36:09 UTC
Oh, Jamie. Excellent use of the drabble form--that last line packs a terrible punch.

Reply

kindkit September 24 2010, 05:32:00 UTC
Thank you! *hugs Jamie*

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

kindkit September 24 2010, 05:34:55 UTC
Thank you!

There's surprisingly little Jamie fic that deal with what Culloden and the defeat of the Stuart cause would mean to him. I can't imagine it didn't occupy his mind at times.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up