Comments | khfanficrants: Kingdom Hearts Idol?

snowangel777_16 in khfanficrants

Kingdom Hearts Idol?

May 21, 2007 13:43

Okay, I'm sure everyone knows what I'm going to rant about. Yes, the somehow always popular Idol fics. Let's take a small look at voice actors, Roxas is voiced by Jesse McCartney, a singer, Kairi is voiced by Hayden Panettiere, also a singer and even Simba is voiced by a singer! In another words, doing a Kingdom Hearts Idol fic is not only ( Read more... )

songfic

Comments 24

vilifier May 21 2007, 17:29:15 UTC

Wait. Kingdom Hearts Idol, like American Idol?

*headdesk* I hate that show, I'd despise that plot if I've ever seen it, but I haven't been to the Pit lately...

snowangel777_16 May 21 2007, 18:46:23 UTC

Yes.

I really hate that show too. And most the plot is just KH characters singing, reviewers are the voters and everyone has an awesome singing voice.

foster9563 May 21 2007, 18:50:07 UTC

everyone has an awesome singing voice.

...Did these people PLAY the Atlantica stages? XD

snowangel777_16 May 21 2007, 18:53:05 UTC

Of course they haven't! It a Disney world.

thesoulwithin May 21 2007, 18:34:26 UTC

Hayden is a SINGER? THE HELL? :O

snowangel777_16 May 21 2007, 18:56:24 UTC

Yeah, she a singer and pretty good one compared to some actress that try to sing, even if they can't. I read on wikipedia that she's amking a CD, but that could be wrong.

akino_ame May 21 2007, 18:45:56 UTC

...Wouldn't an Idol fic be pointless, as the "audience" can't hear the singing?

snowangel777_16 May 21 2007, 19:00:18 UTC

Yeah, but that doesn't stop fanbrats from writing them and people from "voting"

landcow May 21 2007, 19:17:23 UTC

Sounds more like a popularity contest then. Like Kingdom Hearts Survivor on 0KH has turned into

snowangel777_16 May 21 2007, 19:23:42 UTC

Pretty much. Survivor fics are also a pain.

Thread 5

taistoi May 21 2007, 18:55:43 UTC

Idol fics are almost as bad as truth-or-dare fics. WHYYYYY. >_

snowangel777_16 May 21 2007, 18:59:23 UTC

There's truth-or-dare fics?!?! What?! Fandom can be... so dumb.

taistoi May 21 2007, 19:14:59 UTC

Understatement of the century.

snowangel777_16 May 21 2007, 19:20:23 UTC

I know, but I was try to quote a character from a game, but I changed some words.

yui_hime May 21 2007, 19:34:48 UTC

Kairi is voiced by Hayden Panettiere, also a singer

Does this mean that I could write Kairi singing in a fic? 8D *needs to look more of this up on Wikipedia, BRB*

...

Oh, yeah, BACK ON TOPIC... I don't touch American Idol fics. I don't touch Yu-Gi-Oh! Idol, I don't touch Pokemon Idol, I don't touch KH Idol. EVER. Because 11 times out of ten, they're nothing more than badly-written popularity contests where everyone can sing sweetly except the characters nobody likes (which in KH would be all the Disney characters who CANONLY SING WELL), EVERYONE is madly OOC... yeah, I'm going to stop now...

snowangel777_16 May 21 2007, 19:51:49 UTC

I guess so.

It really sad, since some Disney(more like most) character can sing. But your a 100% right about the whole popularity contest, but there was one Idol fic that I read that Kairi had won. It's still the only good Idol fic I've saw.